Fringe elements won't thrive under my watch, says Karnataka Home Minister Priyank Kharge after HC raps Whitefield police
Synopsis
Key Takeaways
Karnataka Home Minister Priyank Kharge on Monday issued a stern warning that 'fringe elements' exploiting the law through social media complaints or claims of hurt religious sentiments will not be tolerated, asserting that unlawful, unscientific, or illogical actions will be dealt with firmly. His remarks follow the Karnataka High Court's sharp rebuke of Bengaluru's Whitefield Police over repeated instances of alleged illegal arrests.
What Kharge Said
Speaking to reporters, Kharge drew a clear line between protecting lawful activities and cracking down on groups that attempt to disrupt them under the guise of hurt sentiments. 'As long as whoever is the entertainer or whoever is the institution that is doing this is well within the law, they will be allowed to function freely in the state of Karnataka,' he said.
He was equally direct about those on the other side: 'These fringe elements who think they can get away by posting things on social media and by claiming to have their feelings hurt — if it is illegal, unscientific or illogical, then it will not be tolerated.' Responding to concerns about such groups gaining ground, Kharge said bluntly, 'I am the Home Minister. They will not thrive. Don't worry.'
The Mohan Gowda Arrest That Triggered the Controversy
The backdrop to Kharge's statement is the case of Mohan Gowda, convenor of the Hindu Janajagruti Samiti, who was detained by Whitefield Police reportedly for sharing a post celebrating the cancellation of Indian comedian Kunal Kamra's show in Bengaluru. Gowda had been served a notice under Section 35(3) of the BNSS to appear before police after three days — yet officers reportedly travelled to Udupi to bring him in, a move the court found difficult to justify.
Kharge also referenced an event that was shifted to another venue after objections were raised, but said the disruption itself was unacceptable: 'The show went on in another venue, but these fringe elements are raising the red flags. That will not be tolerated.'
Karnataka High Court's Scathing Observations
Justice M. Nagaprasanna of the Karnataka High Court questioned the police's conduct in pointed terms on Saturday. 'A constable registers a complaint. All of you travel to Udupi to get the person, the so-called accused, for what? For what, sir? Who is giving you instructions?' the judge asked.
The court also took exception to the handling of CCTV footage, with Whitefield Police citing power fluctuations as the reason for missing footage. Justice Nagaprasanna responded sarcastically, suggesting the station be renamed 'Darkfield Police Station.' He warned that a departmental inquiry could be ordered and that adverse entries could be made in the concerned officer's service record.
'You cannot take the liberty of citizens for granted just because you are in a uniform,' Justice Nagaprasanna said. He added: 'You may escape anybody's eyes, but when it comes to the eyes of the court, you cannot escape.' The bench also remarked that the police action could have been driven by 'someone's ego' and observed, 'This has become — the police themselves have to be policed now. What a state!'
Broader Implications for Law and Order in Karnataka
The episode has placed the Karnataka government under a dual spotlight: scrutiny over police overreach on one hand, and the Home Minister's response to organised pressure groups on the other. The government has maintained that lawful activities will be protected while violations will be handled through due process.
This comes amid a wider national debate over the use of hurt-sentiment complaints as a tool to suppress performances, comedy shows, and public events — a pattern critics argue has been increasingly weaponised. Whether Kharge's warning translates into systemic reform of policing practices in Bengaluru remains to be seen.