Why Did the SC Dismiss the Plea Against Banu Mushtaq Inaugurating Mysuru Dussehra?
Click to start listening
Synopsis
The Supreme Court's recent dismissal of a petition against Banu Mushtaq's inauguration of Mysuru's Dussehra festival has sparked intense debate. With historical significance and cultural implications at stake, this decision highlights the intersection of tradition and modernity in India's diverse landscape.
Key Takeaways
- Supreme Court's ruling affirms inclusivity in cultural celebrations.
- Opposition to Banu Mushtaq's role centers on her past remarks.
- Dussehra festival symbolizes the triumph of good over evil.
- Karnataka government defends its decision as a celebration of culture, not religion.
- Debate continues over the intersection of tradition and modernity.
New Delhi, Sep 19 (NationPress) The Supreme Court has, on Friday, rejected a petition aimed at halting the Congress-led Karnataka government's choice of having Booker Prize laureate Banu Mushtaq inaugurate the renowned Dussehra festival in Mysuru city. A panel of Justices Vikram Nath and Sandeep Mehta found the argument that a non-Hindu individual should not lead pujas unconvincing, especially considering that Banu Mushtaq has previously made remarks deemed offensive to religious sentiments.
On Thursday, Chief Justice of India B.R. Gavai consented to schedule the special leave petition (SLP) for September 19 following an urgent request for its hearing. The SLP challenges the Karnataka High Court's dismissal of public interest litigations (PILs) questioning the state government's decision to invite Banu Mushtaq to inaugurate Dussehra.
The inauguration traditionally involves offering floral tributes to Goddess Chamundeshwari, which has led to opposition against Banu Mushtaq officiating at the festival. In a ruling delivered on September 15, a bench comprising Chief Justice Vibhu Bakhru and Justice C.M. Joshi stated that no rights were infringed, emphasizing that the Vijaya Dashami festival is celebrated nationwide as a symbol of the triumph of good over evil.
Critics labeled the decision to invite Banu Mushtaq as “incorrect,” citing her previous anti-Hindu comments and criticisms of the Kannada language. Reports suggest she has made disparaging remarks about Goddess Bhuvaneshwari and the Kannada flag, which features haldi (yellow) and red (sindoor) colors. One of the PILs, filed by Bengaluru resident H.S. Gourav, argued that inaugurating Dussehra should be an act reserved for Hindu dignitaries.
In contrast, the Karnataka government has reaffirmed its commitment to having Banu Mushtaq inaugurate the festival, asserting that Dussehra represents a 'Nada Habba' (festival of the land) rather than a strictly religious occasion. Deputy Chief Minister and state Congress President D.K. Shivakumar's remark that Chamundi Hills is not solely a Hindu domain has further intensified the debate.
Point of View
It is essential to recognize the Supreme Court's stance as an affirmation of inclusivity in celebrating cultural festivals. While some may view the invitation of Banu Mushtaq as controversial, it reflects a broader dialogue about tradition and modernity, allowing diverse voices to participate in India's vibrant cultural landscape.
NationPress
20/09/2025
Frequently Asked Questions
What was the Supreme Court's decision regarding Banu Mushtaq?
The Supreme Court dismissed a petition against Banu Mushtaq inaugurating the Dussehra festival, ruling that no rights were violated.
Why is Banu Mushtaq's invitation controversial?
Banu Mushtaq has made remarks deemed offensive to Hindu sentiments, leading to opposition against her officiating the festival.
What is the significance of the Dussehra festival?
Dussehra symbolizes the victory of good over evil and is celebrated widely across India, with specific traditions like offering tributes to Goddess Chamundeshwari.
What did the Karnataka government say about the festival?
The Karnataka government described Dussehra as a 'Nada Habba' or festival of the land, asserting it is not solely a religious event.
Who challenged the decision to invite Banu Mushtaq?
Various public interest litigations (PILs) were filed, including one by Bengaluru resident H.S. Gourav, questioning her invitation.
