Is Rahul Gandhi's Comparison of CPI(M) and RSS Justified?
Click to start listening
Synopsis
In a controversial statement, Rahul Gandhi equated the CPI(M) with the RSS, igniting sharp criticism from CPI(M) General Secretary M.A. Baby. This article delves into the implications of Gandhi's comments and the ensuing reactions from Left leaders and political analysts.
Key Takeaways
- Rahul Gandhi's comments have sparked controversy in political circles.
- M.A. Baby labeled the statement as unnecessary.
- Gandhi's remarks highlight issues of empathy in leadership.
- Left leaders criticized Gandhi's political experience.
- The historical context of Congress's actions was brought into the discussion.
New Delhi, July 20 (NationPress) The CPI(M) has expressed strong disapproval regarding Congress leader Rahul Gandhi's assertion that the RSS and the Left party share similarities. Condemning Gandhi's remarks, CPI(M) General Secretary M.A. Baby termed it an unnecessary statement that should not have been articulated.
In an interview with IANS, Baby emphasized that while they often critique the Congress party on various matters, they would never draw parallels between Congress and the BJP.
"We do criticize Congress when necessary, but we would never equate Congress with the BJP. In contrast, Mr. Rahul Gandhi has equated the RSS with the CPI(M), which is an unwanted comment that the Leader of the Opposition should have refrained from making," Baby stated.
During a tribute to former Kerala Chief Minister Oommen Chandy in Puthuppally, Rahul Gandhi, who serves as the Leader of Opposition in the Lok Sabha, claimed that both the RSS and CPI(M) lacked empathy. He made this remark while honoring Chandy on the second anniversary of his passing.
In his speech, Gandhi used the moment to subtly criticize both the CPI(M) and the RSS, suggesting that their leaders are disconnected from the feelings of the populace.
Rahul also accused the CPI(M) of orchestrating a slanderous campaign against Chandy, referencing the controversial solar scam case that the Left party used to target Chandy and the UDF during the elections in 2016 and 2021. Despite Chandy being cleared by the courts, the prolonged legal disputes reportedly affected his health.
The comparison made by Rahul, stating that neither the RSS nor the CPI(M) comprehends empathy, contrasts sharply with the quality Chandy represented. "I oppose them and challenge their ideas through speeches. However, my primary concern is their lack of connection with the people," said Gandhi.
He added, "If leaders do not engage with the people's emotions, they cannot truly lead. The unfortunate reality in Indian politics is that many leaders do not empathize with the populace," remarked the Congress MP.
The Left leaders did not immediately respond to Gandhi's comments. Journalist-turned-Rajya Sabha MP John Brittas, who is aligned with CM Vijayan, criticized Gandhi on social media.
Brittas stated, "The Congress appears to be intent on keeping Rahul Gandhi politically inexperienced," and further remarked, "He and his sister conduct so-called attacks on the RSS from the safety of Wayanad, the stronghold of their ally IUML—taking no risks while reaping rewards."
He added that Congress has a history of hypocrisy, referencing its involvement in "unlocking the gates of Babri Masjid, overseeing its demolition, and fostering the BJP's leadership." Brittas concluded by noting, "Ironically, much of Rahul's understanding of the RSS may have originated from our late leader, Sitaram Yechury."
Point of View
It's important to approach this situation with a balanced perspective. While Rahul Gandhi's comments have sparked controversy, they reflect ongoing tensions in Indian politics. The CPI(M)'s response highlights their commitment to maintaining their identity against perceived threats. It's crucial for political leaders to engage thoughtfully and constructively.
NationPress
20/07/2025
Frequently Asked Questions
What did Rahul Gandhi say about the CPI(M) and RSS?
Rahul Gandhi compared the CPI(M) to the RSS, claiming neither understands empathy during a tribute to former Chief Minister Oommen Chandy.
How did the CPI(M) react to Gandhi's comments?
CPI(M) General Secretary M.A. Baby condemned Gandhi's remarks as an unnecessary statement that should have been avoided.
What historical context did John Brittas provide regarding Congress?
Brittas accused Congress of historical hypocrisy, referencing its role in the Babri Masjid issue and its connection to the BJP.
What was the reaction from Left leaders to Gandhi's statement?
Left leaders, including John Brittas, criticized Gandhi on social media, suggesting he remains politically naive.
Why is the issue of empathy raised by Gandhi significant?
Gandhi's remarks emphasize the disconnect leaders can have with the public, which is critical in a democratic society.
