Could Banu Mushtaq Have Faced Fatal Consequences for Her Remarks on Islam?
Click to start listening
Synopsis
In an unexpected turn of events, BJP MLC C.T. Ravi has made bold claims regarding author Banu Mushtaq's recent comments on cultural symbols. He suggests that had she made similar statements about Islam, the repercussions would have been dire. Discover the details behind this escalating controversy and its implications on cultural sensitivities.
Key Takeaways
- Banu Mushtaq's comments have sparked a significant backlash.
- The BJP is pushing for a withdrawal of her selection for the Dusshera festival.
- C.T. Ravi has raised questions about cultural respect and sensitivity.
- The controversy highlights the tensions between freedom of expression and cultural identity.
- Political leaders are scrutinized for their positions on sensitive issues.
Raichur (Karnataka), Sep 4 (NationPress) Former BJP national general secretary and Karnataka MLC C.T. Ravi has ignited a new controversy by asserting that Booker Prize recipient Banu Mushtaq would have faced being “stoned to death” had she made similar comments regarding Islam, as she supposedly did concerning goddess Bhuvaneshwari and Kannada cultural symbols.
The uproar began after the Congress-led Karnataka government announced Mushtaq's name for inaugurating this year’s historic Dusshera celebrations. The BJP raised objections, referencing a video where Mushtaq allegedly questions the connection between the Kannada language and goddess Bhuvaneshwari while also criticizing the red-and-yellow Kannada flag, which symbolizes haldi and sindoor.
The saffron party has called for the government to retract Mushtaq’s selection, alleging that the name of writer Deepa Bhasti, a Hindu translator of Mushtaq’s work and also a Booker awardee, was intentionally excluded.
During a press briefing in Raichur, Ravi remarked that Mushtaq’s views were “against the culture of this land.”
“Her comments regarding goddess Bhuvaneshwari -- can we cover her in a burqa? We apply sindoor, perform aarti, and present flowers. Can she be draped in a burqa? These statements do not align with our culture,” he stated.
Furthering his criticism, he asserted: “If we were to express anything similar about Islam, the Quran, or Prophet Mohammad, would it be accepted? If Banu Mushtaq had spoken about Islam in the manner she did about goddess Bhuvaneshwari, she would have been stoned to death. We are not advocating for that -- we merely request that she apologize for offending the sentiments of the majority community.”
Ravi also criticized Chief Minister Siddaramaiah for supporting Mushtaq’s selection.
“By failing to demand an apology, the Chief Minister is indirectly endorsing her statements. If he values this land and its language, he should have denounced her remarks. Instead, he is engaging in vote-bank politics,” Ravi claimed.
Point of View
It’s vital to approach this issue with a neutral lens. The statements made by C.T. Ravi highlight the complex interplay between cultural identity and freedom of expression. It’s essential to foster dialogue that respects diverse opinions while maintaining the integrity of cultural symbols.
NationPress
04/09/2025
Frequently Asked Questions
What triggered the controversy involving Banu Mushtaq?
The controversy began when C.T. Ravi claimed that Banu Mushtaq would have faced severe repercussions had she made remarks against Islam similar to those she made about Kannada cultural symbols.
What is the BJP's stance on Mushtaq’s selection?
The BJP has demanded the government revoke Mushtaq's selection for the Dusshera festivities, citing concerns over her previous comments on cultural symbols.
How did C.T. Ravi express his concerns?
C.T. Ravi emphasized that Mushtaq's comments were contrary to local culture and suggested that similar remarks about Islam would not be tolerated.
What did Ravi say about Chief Minister Siddaramaiah?
Ravi criticized Chief Minister Siddaramaiah for not demanding an apology from Mushtaq, accusing him of engaging in vote-bank politics.
What cultural symbols were mentioned in the controversy?
Goddess Bhuvaneshwari and the red-and-yellow Kannada flag were specifically mentioned in the context of Mushtaq's alleged remarks.
