India A must embrace green tops at Lincoln, not fear them: Pamment
Synopsis
Key Takeaways
Former New Zealand assistant coach James Pamment has urged India's Test top-order batters to treat their red-ball preparation at the Bert Sutcliffe Oval in Lincoln as a vital acclimatisation exercise — and, crucially, to resist being intimidated by New Zealand's famously green-tinged pitches ahead of the two-match Test series beginning 19 November.
Why Lincoln is the Ideal Prep Ground
India A open their red-ball series against New Zealand A at the Bert Sutcliffe Oval on Saturday, 25 October, with Pamment — who also served as fielding coach for five-time IPL champions Mumbai Indians — backing the venue as the perfect launchpad for a squad largely unfamiliar with New Zealand conditions.
'They're playing their two games at the Bert Sutcliffe Oval in Lincoln University, aren't they? So, it'll be very, very similar conditions and very similar atmosphere to when they play at Hagley Oval,' Pamment said. He noted that Wellington's Basin Reserve would present 'very green wickets' but with more pace and bounce than lateral movement — a nuance visiting sides often misread.
'Sometimes teams get spooked by the greenness of the wicket, but it actually doesn't seam around too much. It gives great pace and great bounce,' he said, adding that the Christchurch surface would be 'a little bit flatter' before potentially offering some seam before settling. His advice was unambiguous: 'Take the brave option — make sure they're starting that in their preparation down at Bert Sutcliffe Oval, which is a fantastic ground, especially if you've never played in New Zealand before.'
The Scale of India's Task
The stakes for the senior squad could scarcely be higher. India sit fifth in the World Test Championship (WTC) standings and need at minimum a 1-0 result to keep their final berth ambitions alive. Historically, the record is sobering: India have won just two series in New Zealand in 58 years, the most recent coming in 2009 when their top-order collectively amassed 899 runs across three Tests.
Only three members of the current Test squad — Ravindra Jadeja, Rishabh Pant, and Jasprit Bumrah — have previously played a Test in New Zealand. The tour falls in November, well before the peak of the New Zealand summer, meaning seam-friendly conditions are near-certain.
At least nine members of the Test squad — KL Rahul, Yashasvi Jaiswal, Devdutt Padikkal, Dhruv Jurel, B Sai Sudharsan, Washington Sundar, Akash Deep, Anshul Kamboj, and Pant (subject to recovering from a left side strain) — are scheduled for up to three red-ball matches between 24 October and 10 November to sharpen their readiness.
Batting Mindset and Historical Lessons
Pamment emphasised mental approach as much as technical preparation. 'It's really important that they don't get spooked by the green wickets. That's the most important thing — that they remain positive, try to take the game on and advance it, rather than thinking, oh, it's green wickets, we're going to have to fiddle around here and try and survive,' he said.
The historical record underlines the point. In the 2009 series win, then-player Gautam Gambhir — now India's head coach — batted 643 minutes and faced 436 balls for an innings of 137 to save the Napier Test. But on the 2014 and 2020 tours, India's top-order failed to replicate that fortitude and suffered series defeats on both occasions. The onus now falls heavily on Rahul, Jaiswal, and Padikkal, with New Zealand's own top-order averaging a formidable 45.03 in Tests at home since 2024.
Bowling Balance: Why India Must Play a Spinner
On team composition, Pamment was emphatic that an all-pace attack would be a strategic error. 'You definitely have to play a spinner. For sure you have to play a spinner because if the game in Wellington does go the distance a little bit longer... the game can go deep. So, you always need to play a spinner and I don't think they need to just go for a total seam attack. I think it's definitely 3-1 would be my recommendation,' he said, pointing to Jadeja's dual value as an all-rounder as a key differentiator.
Pamment also backed Nitish Kumar Reddy as a vital balance option. 'Somebody like Nitish Kumar Reddy in the middle order, and then Jadeja, just allows you to play those three specialist seamers, one specialist spinner and an all-rounder. That's the right balance,' he said, noting New Zealand might adopt a broadly similar structure.
The New Zealand Pace Threat and One Key Absence
Pamment identified bounce — rather than swing — as the primary challenge India's batters would face. He singled out Matt Henry as 'one of the world's best bowlers in Test match cricket over the last two or three years,' praising his consistency of line and length combined with the ability to move the ball both ways. Kyle Jamieson's extra bounce, Jacob Duffy's wicket-taking record across formats in the past calendar year, and Blair Tickner's pace and height were also flagged as threats.
One significant absentee, however, works in India's favour: William O'Rourke has been rested from the India series as New Zealand manage his workload ahead of the subsequent Australia tour. 'He's a big miss for New Zealand,' Pamment acknowledged, though he added that the broader seam-bowling crop remained 'demanding.' He also highlighted Nathan Smith — 'very accurate' and 'moves the ball laterally' — as a bowler India must engage proactively rather than allow to settle into rhythm.
With WTC final places on the line for both sides, Pamment concluded: 'India has got a little bit of work to do, but hey, they have the quality. They just haven't quite got it together in some series.' The coming weeks at Lincoln may well determine how much of that quality translates when it counts most.