Why Did Kerala HC Grant Bail to Six Juveniles Accused of Murdering a 15-Year-Old?
Click to start listening
Synopsis
In a controversial ruling, the Kerala High Court has granted bail to six juveniles accused in the tragic murder of 15-year-old Shahabas. This decision has sparked outrage from the victim's family, highlighting the complexities of juvenile justice in India. As the fight for justice continues, the community grapples with the implications of this ruling.
Key Takeaways
- Kerala High Court grants bail to six juveniles accused of murder.
- The decision has sparked significant public outcry.
- Shahabas succumbed to injuries sustained in a school fight.
- Legal considerations for juveniles differ from adult offenders.
- Continued advocacy for justice from the victim's family.
Kochi, June 11 (NationPress) The Kerala High Court has approved bail for six juveniles involved in the murder of 15-year-old Shahabas, despite the victim's father vehemently opposing the ruling and vowing to continue his fight for justice.
This decision comes a week after the court instructed the Superintendent of the Observation Home in Kozhikode to facilitate the admission of these accused individuals into different schools.
On Wednesday, Justice Bechu Kurian Thomas issued the bail order, allowing their release from the Kozhikode Observation Home upon the personal bond of their parents.
In granting bail, the court emphasized that observation homes are not designed for extended confinement, especially when the juveniles have no prior criminal history.
Additionally, the court required the parents to submit affidavits and made it clear that the juveniles must assist in the ongoing investigation and avoid any criminal conduct.
The father of Shahabas stated that he had remained silent until now, but after today's events, he feels compelled to speak out against the perceived injustice.
Last month, the High Court intervened on behalf of these juveniles after the state government withheld their examination results.
Following this intervention, state Education Minister V. Sivankutty announced their Class 10 results, confirming that all had passed and were eligible for further studies.
Shahabas was a student at MJ Higher Secondary School, Thamarassery, Kozhikode, and succumbed to severe injuries on March 1 after an altercation between students from his school and Thamarassery GVHSS, which arose from a dispute during a farewell event at a tuition center in late February.
Despite teachers attempting to mediate through a series of WhatsApp messages, tensions escalated, leading to a violent confrontation near the tuition center.
Shahabas sustained critical head injuries that ultimately resulted in his death.
Police have filed murder charges against the accused, stating that they used weapons such as a truncheon and a nunchaku during the assault on Shahabas.
Although Shahabas was not a student at the tuition center, he was called to the location while running an errand.
After the incident, a friend transported him home. Initially, his family suspected drug use when they discovered him in a weakened condition.
Upon uncovering the truth, he was hurriedly taken to Thamarassery Taluk Hospital and subsequently transferred to Kozhikode Government Medical College and Hospital, where he later passed away.
All accused students have been in judicial custody since then and also took their examinations while in custody.
–IANS
sg/vd
Point of View
It is crucial to recognize the delicate balance between justice for victims and the rehabilitation of juvenile offenders. The ruling by the Kerala High Court emphasizes the need for a nuanced approach towards juvenile justice, which must consider both the rights of the accused and the pain of the victims’ families. It is a reminder of the complexities inherent in our legal system.
NationPress
12/06/2025
Frequently Asked Questions
What were the charges against the juveniles?
The juveniles were charged with murder after the tragic death of 15-year-old Shahabas, who sustained severe injuries during a violent altercation.
What did the Kerala High Court decide?
The Kerala High Court granted bail to the six juveniles, emphasizing that observation homes are not meant for prolonged detention, especially for those with no prior criminal records.
What was the reaction of Shahabas's family?
Shahabas's father expressed strong discontent with the court's decision, stating he will actively seek justice for his son.
What were the circumstances leading to Shahabas's death?
Shahabas was attacked during a fight between students from different schools, which intensified over a dispute at a tuition center farewell event.
What are the implications of this case?
This case raises critical questions about juvenile justice and the appropriate balance between rehabilitation and accountability.
