Indian teen Romanch Mahajan's family sues New York for $105 million over carriage death
Synopsis
Key Takeaways
The family of Romanch Mahajan, an 18-year-old Indian teenager from Pathankot who died after a horse-drawn carriage accident in Central Park, New York, has filed a $105 million compensation claim against New York City, alleging government negligence caused the 17 June 2024 tragedy. The notice, filed last week against the city and four of its departments, marks the first formal step toward a court lawsuit.
What the Family Alleges
According to the notice, stray electricity in Central Park spooked the horse, causing it to bolt. The family contends this was among the factors that 'caused, precipitated, contributed to and/or was a substantial factor' in triggering the runaway carriage. They argue the incident was a direct consequence of the city government's failure to maintain a safe environment for visitors.
The family had travelled to New York to celebrate Mahajan's graduation from Angel's Public School, where he had recently completed his 12th standard. On the evening of the accident, the carriage driver stepped off the vehicle to take a photograph, at which point the horse bolted. Mahajan's mother, Priya Mahajan, was thrown from the carriage. In an attempt to save her, Romanch jumped after her, struck his head on the ground, and succumbed to the injury.
Union's Stray Voltage Claim
The family's allegation about stray electrical voltage echoes a position already taken by the Transport Workers Union, to which carriage driver Ertan Gokdepe belonged. Alexander Kemp, Vice President of the union's local unit, said last month: 'Blue-collar carriage drivers should not be punished for an unforeseeable hazard caused by flaws in the city's power grid.' The convergence of the family's legal claim with the union's defence puts the spotlight squarely on the city's infrastructure accountability.
Father's Emotional Appeal to City Council
Mahajan's father, Deepak Mahajan, addressed the New York City Council via video link last month, making an emotional plea for a ban on horse-drawn carriages. 'A young boy came to America full of dreams and left us far too soon,' he said. He further stated: 'This was not an unpredictable accident. It was a safety violation, a system's failure to protect the people who visit our city, your city, and everyone responsible has admitted the driver should never have left that carriage.'
The Romanch Mahajan Bill and What Comes Next
Romanch's death has given significant momentum to advocacy efforts seeking to ban horse-drawn carriages — a long-standing tourist attraction in New York City. The proposed legislation, named the Romanch Mahajan Bill in his memory, is expected to come before the City Council for a vote soon. Supporters say the bill currently has majority backing to pass. If enacted, it would mark a historic end to a practice that has faced safety and animal welfare criticism for years. The $105 million lawsuit, meanwhile, is expected to proceed to court following the statutory notice period.