Sam Pitroda: India lagging on AI despite Indian talent shaping the field
Synopsis
Key Takeaways
Senior Congress leader Sam Pitroda has said that India remains poorly positioned in Artificial Intelligence (AI) as a nation, even as Indian technologists continue to play an outsized role in shaping the global industry. Speaking in New York on 28 August, Pitroda called for AI to be deployed urgently in India's courts, schools, healthcare system, and agriculture sector.
India vs Indians on AI
'India is in a bad position in AI. I'm sorry to say that. I don't like to say that. Believe me. Indians are in a good position on AI. Two separate things,' Pitroda said in an interview.
'There are a lot of Indian brains who shape AI. But as a nation, we have made very little progress. We have no policy on AI. We have no direction on AI. We have not used AI for our governance,' he added.
The distinction Pitroda draws is pointed: individual talent has flourished globally, but the Indian state has yet to harness that talent for domestic transformation. This comes amid growing global competition in AI policy, with the United States, China, and the European Union each having advanced regulatory and investment frameworks in place.
Where AI should be deployed, according to Pitroda
Pitroda, who played a central role in India's telecommunications and information technology expansion, argued that the true measure of AI progress should be its impact on ordinary citizens.
He cited India's vast judicial backlog as a priority use case. 'Can I use AI to settle my court cases? Finish. Can I just have a project, special technology mission on AI to settle court cases? Get that done, then I'd be very happy,' he said.
Beyond courts, he pressed for AI applications in education, healthcare cost reduction, and agricultural productivity. 'How is AI going to improve our education? How AI is going to improve our health system? Can AI bring the cost of health system down? How is AI going to be helpful to our farmers? Those are the issues,' he said.
Pitroda explicitly distanced himself from AI development aimed at financial markets or Western economic problems. 'Designing AI for solving Western world problem or some banking problem or some stock market thing is okay. It doesn't interest me,' he said.
Made for India, made for the world
Pitroda rejected the argument that India-focused AI solutions would lack global relevance. He contended that products built to solve India's problems — judicial backlogs, rural healthcare, farm productivity — would find ready application across developing nations facing similar challenges.
'When you make made for India, it becomes made for world. Today, every product is a global, global product. It depends on what problem you are trying to solve,' he said. He pointed to comparable judicial backlog problems in Latin America as one example of where India-designed solutions could travel.
India's IT legacy and what it must build next
Pitroda recalled India's early investments in indigenous technology development through institutions such as the Centre for Development of Telematics (C-DOT) and the Centre for Development of Advanced Computing (C-DAC), both established roughly 45 years ago. Those efforts, he said, seeded the human capital that later powered India's IT sector.
'Seven million jobs in IT, seven million families lifted from poverty, at least, through IT. World recognition on IT. It is human talent from India,' he said.
He argued that this same talent must now be redirected toward the problems of the poor, both in India and across developing countries, rather than being concentrated on commercially lucrative challenges in wealthy markets. 'Best brains in the world are busy solving problems of the rich, who really don't have problems to solve. As a result, problems of the poor don't get the attention they need,' he said.
Pitroda is widely associated with the establishment of C-DOT and the expansion of public telecommunications under former Prime Minister Rajiv Gandhi. He later headed the National Knowledge Commission under former Prime Minister Manmohan Singh, and has advised Congress leaders on technology and public policy for several decades. Whether his call for a national AI mission gains traction in India's current policy environment remains to be seen.