Is SIR Acceptable Only If the Current Lok Sabha is Dismantled? Abhishek Banerjee Speaks Out

Click to start listening
Is SIR Acceptable Only If the Current Lok Sabha is Dismantled? Abhishek Banerjee Speaks Out

Synopsis

In a bold statement, Abhishek Banerjee demands the dismantling of the current Parliament before accepting the ECI's Special Intensive Revision. He argues that the flawed voters’ list used in previous elections taints the legitimacy of elected officials, including the Prime Minister. This controversial stance ignites intense debate over election integrity.

Key Takeaways

  • Banerjee's Call for Dismantling Parliament: He insists the current Lok Sabha is illegitimate due to past electoral manipulation.
  • Legal Action against Former ECI Chief: Banerjee demands accountability for the compromised elections.
  • Opposition's Peaceful Protest: The use of force by police against the Opposition MPs raises concerns about civil liberties.
  • ECI's Commitment to Transparency: The Election Commission defends its actions and maintains it operates transparently.
  • Electoral Integrity at Stake: The discussion around SIR highlights the critical issues surrounding election credibility in India.

Kolkata, Aug 12 (NationPress) The General Secretary of the Trinamool Congress and the party's leader in the Lok Sabha, Abhishek Banerjee, asserted on Tuesday that the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) proposed by the Election Commission of India (ECI) is only acceptable if the existing Parliament is dissolved.

“If I concede that SIR is necessary due to manipulations in the voters’ list, then you must also recognize that the previous Lok Sabha elections were held with that tainted voters’ list. Therefore, the current Parliament ought to be dismantled. Since both the Prime Minister and the Union Home Minister were elected based on that altered voters' list, they should resign as well. Additionally, there have been Assembly elections in certain states with a compromised voters' list. Thus, the Assemblies in those states should also be disbanded,” Banerjee stated to reporters outside the Kolkata Airport prior to his departure for Delhi in the afternoon.

He further emphasized that legal proceedings should be initiated against former Chief Election Commissioner Rajiv Kumar for overseeing elections conducted with such a manipulated voters' list.

In his remarks, he mentioned that the Delhi Police applied undue force against the Opposition MPs’ peaceful march towards the ECI office on Monday.

“We had straightforward questions. Why is the SIR being enforced? Why hasn’t a digital voters’ list been implemented after all these years? However, the ECI officials refused to respond to these inquiries, leading to our exclusion,” Banerjee remarked.

On the previous day, the ECI issued a fact-check categorically rejecting as “incorrect” the statements made by protesting Opposition leaders concerning alleged 'voter list manipulation'.

Providing insights about discussions held with political entities prior to, during, and following the publication of the draft electoral roll in Bihar, the ECI stated that it maintains the highest level of transparency in this process.

Claiming that accurate electoral rolls fortify democracy, the ECI reissued the formal order for Special Intensive Revision in Bihar and provided links to videos showcasing testimonials from representatives of various political parties, including Congress, Rashtriya Janata Dal, and the Left.

The ECI’s fact-check coincided with a day when Rahul Gandhi, the Leader of Opposition in the Lok Sabha, led a unified protest march of the INDIA bloc parties from Parliament to the ECI’s office at Nirvachan Sadan in Delhi.

Point of View

It is crucial to approach this situation with an unbiased lens. Abhishek Banerjee's demands for the dismantling of Parliament highlight significant concerns regarding electoral integrity in India. The implications for democracy are profound, and it is essential to ensure that discussions around the Special Intensive Revision are grounded in factual transparency and accountability.
NationPress
20/08/2025

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the Special Intensive Revision (SIR)?
The Special Intensive Revision (SIR) is a process proposed by the Election Commission of India to correct and update the electoral rolls, ensuring they reflect the accurate voter demographic.
Why does Abhishek Banerjee want Parliament dismantled?
Banerjee argues that since the last Lok Sabha elections were conducted using a manipulated voters’ list, the current Parliament lacks legitimacy and should be dismantled.
What actions does Banerjee suggest against the former Chief Election Commissioner?
He calls for legal action against former Chief Election Commissioner Rajiv Kumar, asserting that elections held under his leadership were compromised.
What was the ECI's response to allegations of voter list manipulation?
The Election Commission issued a fact-check refuting claims of voter list manipulation by Opposition leaders, emphasizing their commitment to transparency.
What actions were taken against the Opposition's peaceful march?
Banerjee criticized the Delhi Police for using excessive force against the Opposition MPs who were peacefully marching towards the ECI office.