Why Is BJP Criticizing CM Siddaramaiah Over Caste Census?

Click to start listening
Why Is BJP Criticizing CM Siddaramaiah Over Caste Census?

Synopsis

In a heated exchange, the Karnataka BJP criticizes Chief Minister Siddaramaiah's remarks on the caste census, deeming the Congress-led government's previous efforts a model of failure. With a call for transparency and proper execution, the BJP emphasizes their commitment to social justice. Is this a political maneuver or genuine dedication to the caste census?

Key Takeaways

  • BJP criticizes Congress for its handling of the caste census.
  • CM Siddaramaiah offers support to the Union government.
  • Debate centers on transparency and proper execution of census initiatives.
  • Both parties claim commitment to social justice.
  • Historical context includes BJP's past support for caste enumeration.

Bengaluru, May 1 (NationPress) The Karnataka BJP harshly criticized Chief Minister Siddaramaiah regarding his comments on the caste census, asserting that the initiative undertaken by the Congress-led government exemplifies how not to conduct such a census.

Previously, CM Siddaramaiah expressed his government’s readiness to provide any necessary guidance to the Union government concerning the caste census.

R. Ashoka, the Leader of Opposition in the Legislative Assembly, remarked, “Chief Minister Siddaramaiah, your suggestion that Karnataka's model should be emulated for the caste census is quite amusing. A report that has lost its original copy, lacks signatures from secretaries, includes applications filled out by school children who were paid five to ten rupees per form, and skips enumeration of households with dogs, all while remaining unaccepted after ten years—your caste census report is a classic example of how not to conduct a caste census.”

He further stated, “Your assertion that the BJP has consistently opposed the caste census is a blatant falsehood. In 2010, the late Sushma Swaraj, then Leader of Opposition in the Lok Sabha, formally communicated to the UPA government that the BJP backed the inclusion of caste enumeration in the 2011 census. The BJP also endorsed the unanimous resolution passed in Parliament on this issue,” Ashoka clarified.

Instead of executing a legitimate caste census, the previous Congress government conducted a flawed Social-Economic Caste Census in 2011 (SECC-2011). Like Karnataka's caste census, this initiative also suffered from inadequate planning and execution, leading to its total failure. Despite the expenditure of crores of rupees, the findings were never officially disclosed. This highlights the Congress party's authentic commitment to the caste census, Ashoka remarked.

“The BJP has never exploited the caste census for electoral advantage. While in power, we pledged to carry out the caste census. We did not engage in petty politics by expressing sympathy when in opposition and neglecting the issue when in power. This reflects our sincere commitment to social justice. Our main concern regarding the caste census has always been to ensure it is not misused for political attacks,” Ashoka emphasized.

“The caste census that the Central government is now preparing to conduct will be undertaken in an entirely transparent, scientific, and purposeful manner—unlike the manipulation for political gain that your Congress government engaged in by distorting data to suit your needs,” Ashoka stated, addressing CM Siddaramaiah directly.

He reiterated that Karnataka’s caste census process serves solely as a cautionary example of how not to conduct a caste census; there is nothing from it worth emulating.

Welcoming the central government's decision to conduct a caste census, CM Siddaramaiah stated on Wednesday, “Just as the BJP initially ridiculed our five guarantee schemes and subsequently adopted them, the Modi government’s decision to implement a caste census proves that Congress’ policies are fundamentally geared towards public welfare.

“The Karnataka government’s caste-based Social, Economic, and Educational Survey is a solid model. We are fully equipped to provide any assistance or guidance the Union government may require,” the CM mentioned.

CM Siddaramaiah added, “Our government fully supports the Union government’s decision to conduct a caste census in conjunction with the national population census. At this juncture, I urge the Union government to also perform a social, economic, and educational survey alongside the census. In Karnataka, we did more than just conduct a caste census; we also collected data on the social, economic, and educational circumstances of communities. Based on this data, we have made modifications and expansions to the current reservation policy. I hope the Union government will now pursue this process as well.”

Point of View

It is crucial to recognize that political discourse around caste census initiatives often reflects deeper societal issues. The ongoing debate between the BJP and Congress illustrates the complexities of caste-based policies in India. While both parties claim to prioritize social justice, their approaches may vary significantly. It is essential to keep a neutral lens while reporting on these developments, focusing on factual representation and public interest.
NationPress
2025-05-01T08:14:11.285Z

Frequently Asked Questions

What did CM Siddaramaiah say about the caste census?
CM Siddaramaiah expressed his readiness to assist the Union government in conducting a caste census, emphasizing the importance of such an initiative.
How did the BJP respond to Siddaramaiah's remarks?
The BJP criticized Siddaramaiah, claiming that the Congress-led government's previous caste census efforts were poorly executed and served as a model of failure.
What historical context did the BJP provide regarding the caste census?
The BJP mentioned that in 2010, they supported caste enumeration in the census, countering claims that they opposed the initiative.
What concerns did the BJP express about the caste census?
The BJP voiced concerns that the caste census should not be manipulated for political gains, emphasizing the need for transparency and scientific methodology.
What is the significance of the caste census in Indian politics?
The caste census is significant as it impacts social justice policies and reservation systems, influencing electoral politics and community representation.