Calcutta HC issues show-cause notice to Abhishek Banerjee over judiciary remarks
Synopsis
Key Takeaways
A single-judge bench of the Calcutta High Court on Tuesday, 17 November 2026, issued a show-cause notice to Abhishek Banerjee, General Secretary of the All India Trinamool Congress (TMC) and Diamond Harbour Lok Sabha member, over his recent remarks alleging that a section of the judiciary was 'biased'. The bench, presided over by Justice Krishan Rao, directed Banerjee to respond within 15 days explaining why the court should not initiate proceedings against him for the comments. The next hearing has been scheduled for 8 December.
What the Court Observed
Justice Rao noted that Banerjee, as an elected Member of Parliament, had through his remarks attempted to influence the trial system and had made what the court termed 'disgraceful allegations' against the judiciary. The bench sought an explanation as to why disciplinary action should not be initiated against him in light of these alleged attempts to influence court proceedings.
Justice Rao's reaction was notably stern. He reportedly directed Banerjee's counsel to furnish a complete list of which judges the MP considered aligned with the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) and which with the Trinamool Congress. 'Ask your client which judges are with the BJP and which are not! He thinks he is very intelligent. Ask him to give a list; I will look into it,' Justice Rao said in court.
How the Issue Came Before the Court
The matter surfaced on 12 November during the final hearing of a petition filed by Abhishek Banerjee seeking restoration of his 'Z-Plus' security cover. Billawdal Bhattacharya, West Bengal's Additional Advocate General, drew the court's attention to a social media message posted by Banerjee in which he allegedly made remarks directly challenging the country's judicial system and the dignity of the courts. Bhattacharya urged the court to intervene and take strong legal action against the Diamond Harbour MP.
Banerjee's counsel, in response, contended that the comments were made in the context of petitions filed by his client having remained pending before the court for several months. Justice Rao expressed sharp displeasure at this explanation.
Background and Context
Abhishek Banerjee is the nephew of West Bengal Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee and one of the most prominent second-generation leaders within the TMC. He has been at the centre of several legal battles in recent years, including those related to his security detail and alleged links to post-poll violence cases. Last week, Justice Rao had already expressed anguish over the reported remarks before formally issuing Tuesday's notice.
This episode comes amid a broader pattern of friction between elected representatives and the judiciary across multiple states, raising questions about contempt boundaries and the limits of political commentary on court proceedings. Notably, this is not the first time a sitting MP has faced judicial scrutiny over remarks about the courts, though the directness of Justice Rao's response — asking for a named list of allegedly partisan judges — is unusual.
What Happens Next
Banerjee has 15 days to file his reply to the show-cause notice. The case will return before Justice Rao's bench on 8 December, when the court will assess his response and decide whether to proceed with contempt or disciplinary action. Legal observers note that the outcome could set a significant precedent regarding elected officials' public commentary on pending judicial matters.