Are Haryana and Rajasthan Pressuring Punjab to Surrender Its Rights?

Click to start listening
Are Haryana and Rajasthan Pressuring Punjab to Surrender Its Rights?

Synopsis

In a recent statement, Punjab's Chief Minister Bhagwant Singh Mann firmly rejected claims of excess water availability for sharing. He accused Haryana and Rajasthan of exerting unjust pressure on Punjab to claim its rights, emphasizing the need for accurate assessment of water resources.

Key Takeaways

  • Punjab has no extra water to share with neighboring states.
  • Haryana and Rajasthan are pressuring Punjab for water rights.
  • The Northern Zonal Council meeting highlighted inter-state tensions.
  • Punjab's government is committed to defending its rights.
  • Water resource management remains a critical issue for agriculture.

New Delhi, Nov 18 (NationPress) Asserting that Punjab lacks additional water to distribute, Chief Minister Bhagwant Singh Mann stated on Tuesday that Haryana, Rajasthan, and Himachal Pradesh are unjustly exerting pressure on Punjab to take away its rightful share of resources.

The Chief Minister noted that during the Northern Zonal Council (NZC) meeting, each state expressed its views. However, he highlighted that a majority of the states, including Haryana, Rajasthan, and Himachal Pradesh, are determined to infringe upon Punjab’s rights.

“It is regrettable that Haryana, Rajasthan, and Himachal Pradesh are unnecessarily pressing Punjab to seize our rights,” the Chief Minister told reporters. He criticized the irresponsible leadership of these states for making unreasonable demands for a share in Punjab’s resources and river waters.

Mann explained that during the meeting, he represented Punjab’s interests, and out of 28 agenda items, 11 pertained to Punjab, all of which were deferred due to his government’s efforts. He pointed out that these issues were created by his predecessors - the Akalis, BJP, and Congress - and emphasized his administration's commitment to resolving them.

Highlighting the importance of accurately assessing river water availability, Mann stated that those clamoring for a share must understand that Punjab has no surplus water to share. He firmly asserted that the government is committed to defending Punjab’s interests and will take necessary actions to do so.

The Chief Minister addressed Haryana's unusual demand that Punjab halt mini-hydro project constructions on the Bhakra Main Line (BML), claiming it would disrupt the water flow. He expressed surprise at Haryana's leadership for making such unfounded claims.

Mann reiterated that issues surrounding the Satluj Yamuna Link (SYL) could only be resolved through the Yamuna Satluj Link (YSL), which would facilitate fair utilization of the Yamuna water. He underscored that Punjab has no extra water to spare through the SYL and criticized the absence of scientific assessments regarding water availability.

He emphasized that Punjab cannot share any extra water with other states, especially in light of the suspension of the Indus Water Treaty, which presents an opportunity to resolve inter-state water disputes. Mann suggested exploring options to connect the Chenab river with the Ravi and Beas rivers, where existing dams manage downstream water flow.

On the subject of the Bhakra Beas Management Board (BBMB), Mann opposed adding a full-time member from Rajasthan, asserting that the board is governed by the Punjab Reorganisation Act of 1966 and pertains solely to Punjab and Haryana. He noted that Rajasthan and Himachal Pradesh already have representation as ex officio members and creating additional positions would only escalate costs, primarily borne by Punjab.

Point of View

A critical issue for agriculture and sustainability in the region. As the government navigates these complex dynamics, it is essential for all parties to engage in constructive dialogue to ensure equitable resource distribution.
NationPress
18/11/2025

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the main issue between Punjab and neighboring states?
The primary issue involves Punjab's refusal to share its water resources with Haryana and Rajasthan, who are exerting pressure for a share of the state's water rights.
How is Punjab addressing the water rights issue?
Punjab's Chief Minister has stated that the state has no surplus water to share and emphasized the need for accurate assessments of water availability.
What is the significance of the Northern Zonal Council meeting?
The Northern Zonal Council meeting provided a platform for states to discuss their views on water rights, but Punjab's interests were notably defended by its Chief Minister.
What proposals did Punjab suggest for resolving water disputes?
Punjab proposed exploring the linkage of the Chenab river with the Ravi and Beas rivers to utilize surplus water effectively.
Who are the political parties mentioned in the context of this issue?
The parties referenced include the Akalis, BJP, and Congress, which the Chief Minister accused of creating the current water-related problems.
Nation Press