Did Irinjalakuda Diocese in Kerala Criticize Archbishop Pamplany for Praising the Centre Over Nuns' Release?
Click to start listening
Synopsis
In a notable turn of events, the Irinjalakuda Diocese in Kerala has openly challenged Archbishop Pamplany's praise for the Central government regarding the release of two nuns. This article delves into the controversy and highlights the Church's official stance amidst rising tensions.
Key Takeaways
- The Irinjalakuda Diocese publicly criticized Archbishop Pamplany for his praise of the Central government.
- Bishop Mar Pauly Kannookadan emphasized that only Church leaders can articulate the official Church stance.
- The pastoral letter expressed disappointment over the nuns' arrest and the government's inaction.
- Legal action against right-wing organizations was called for by the diocese.
- A protest rally is scheduled, highlighting ongoing tensions surrounding the Church.
Thiruvananthapuram, Aug 3 (NationPress) The Irinjalakuda Diocese in Kerala has formally criticized Thalassery Archbishop Joseph Pamplany for his comments praising Prime Minister Narendra Modi and Union Home Minister Amit Shah regarding their alleged role in the release of two nuns detained in Chhattisgarh.
Bishop Mar Pauly Kannookadan, the head of the Irinjalakuda Diocese, emphasized that only recognized Church leaders have the authority to convey the Church's official stance.
"Only Church heads are entitled to articulate the Church’s position. Personal views do not represent the official stance," the bishop stated, subtly criticizing Pamplany’s public support for the Central government.
Pamplany had informed the media on Saturday that the Central government made "genuine efforts" to facilitate the release of the nuns and insinuated that the Chhattisgarh government had hindered the process.
In contrast, the Irinjalakuda Diocese released a pastoral letter during Sunday Mass in all its churches, vehemently condemning both the Central and Chhattisgarh governments. The letter voiced profound disappointment over the nuns' arrest and criticized the Centre for its silence amidst widespread protests nationwide and in Parliament.
The pastoral letter indicated that although the nuns qualified for bail, they were mired in unnecessary legal issues.
"The bail granted to the nuns is not a relief but is accompanied by strict conditions. The charges must be dismissed, and the charge sheet annulled," demanded Bishop Kannookadan.
The diocese also called for legal action against right-wing groups, including the Bajrang Dal, which initiated the original complaint. The Bishop urged the Centre to take measures against such extremist organizations and address the actions of the train ticket examiner allegedly involved in the situation.
Sisters Preethi Mary and Vandana Francis were apprehended by railway police at Durg station on July 25, alongside Sukaman Mandavi, following allegations from a Bajrang Dal member accusing them of trafficking and forcibly converting three tribal girls. The nuns regained their freedom nine days later after obtaining bail from a special NIA court.
A protest rally is set to occur in Chalakudy on Sunday evening as part of the diocese's ongoing demonstrations against what they describe as an "unjust and communal" targeting of the Church.
Point of View
The incident involving the Irinjalakuda Diocese and Archbishop Pamplany reflects broader issues of authority and representation within religious institutions. It highlights the need for clarity in leadership roles, especially in politically sensitive matters. The Church's response signifies a commitment to its values and community, aligning with the principles that uphold its integrity.
NationPress
08/10/2025
Frequently Asked Questions
What led to the Irinjalakuda Diocese's rebuke of Archbishop Pamplany?
The Irinjalakuda Diocese rebuked Archbishop Pamplany for his remarks praising the Central government for its involvement in the release of two nuns detained in Chhattisgarh, asserting that only authorized Church leaders can convey official positions.
What was the response of the Irinjalakuda Diocese regarding the nuns' arrest?
The Diocese issued a pastoral letter criticizing both the Central and Chhattisgarh governments, expressing disappointment over the arrest and calling for the charges against the nuns to be dropped.
Who were the nuns arrested and what were the allegations against them?
Sisters Preethi Mary and Vandana Francis were arrested along with Sukaman Mandavi based on allegations from a Bajrang Dal member accusing them of trafficking and forcibly converting three tribal girls.
