Can a Beggar Be Forced to Pay Maintenance? Kerala High Court Says No!
Click to start listening
Synopsis
In a groundbreaking ruling, the Kerala High Court declared that a beggar cannot be forced to pay maintenance to his wife. This case sheds light on the complexities of marital obligations and the necessity for state intervention to support vulnerable spouses. Can the legal system balance justice and compassion in such unique situations?
Key Takeaways
- The Kerala High Court ruled against forcing a beggar to pay maintenance.
- State intervention is required to support destitute spouses.
- Justice P.V. Kunhikrishnan emphasized the need for counseling in polygamous marriages.
- Polygamy is permissible only for men who can fairly maintain multiple wives.
- Allegations of abuse were noted but difficult to substantiate.
Kochi, Sep 20 (IANS) The Kerala High Court has determined that a court cannot mandate a beggar to provide maintenance to his spouse, while instructing the state to intervene to ensure that impoverished partners receive basic necessities such as food and clothing.
This ruling emerged from an unusual case where a woman sought maintenance from her blind husband, who depends on begging for survival.
Justice P.V. Kunhikrishnan noted that it is inappropriate to require someone who relies on alms to financially support others, referencing a Malayalam proverb, 'one should not dip into another person’s begging bowl'.
The case involved a man married twice under Muslim Personal Law, with his second wife demanding Rs 10,000 monthly for maintenance.
Previously, the Family Court in Malappuram dismissed her request, stating that a beggar cannot be ordered to provide maintenance, leading to the appeal in the High Court.
Justice Kunhikrishnan upheld the Family Court's ruling but stressed that the State must ensure both wives receive necessary support.
He also pointed out that multiple marriages without the ability to support current wives are troubling and called for adequate counseling for those involved.
The Court reviewed allegations of physical abuse by the blind husband against his wife, acknowledging the difficulty in accepting such claims but recognizing the potential for mental or other forms of cruelty.
It was noted that the husband threatened to declare Talaq on his second wife and remarry, highlighting the dangers posed by uneducated men practicing polygamy without the means to support their families.
Justice Kunhikrishnan referred to Muslim Personal Law and Quranic principles, clarifying that polygamy is permissible only for men capable of fairly maintaining multiple wives, emphasizing that monogamy is intended to be the standard.
The High Court has mandated that a copy of the ruling be forwarded to the Kerala Social Welfare Department for professional counseling of the husband, including guidance from religious leaders, to prevent him from engaging in another marriage.
Point of View
This ruling highlights the delicate balance between legal obligations and the realities of poverty. While the court rightly protects the rights of the beggar, it also underscores the pressing need for government intervention to support vulnerable spouses. The case raises vital questions about the responsibilities of individuals in polygamous relationships and the role of the state in safeguarding the welfare of all citizens.
NationPress
20/09/2025
Frequently Asked Questions
Can a beggar be compelled to pay maintenance?
No, according to the Kerala High Court ruling, a beggar cannot be forced to pay maintenance to a spouse.
What did the Kerala High Court decide about state support?
The court directed the state to ensure that destitute spouses receive essential support, including food and clothing.
What was the context of the ruling?
The ruling arose from a case where a woman sought maintenance from her blind husband who survives by begging.
