Why Did K'taka CM Condemn the Shoe-Throwing Incident at CJI Gavai?
Click to start listening
Synopsis
Karnataka's CM Siddaramaiah condemned the shoe-throwing incident at CJI B.R. Gavai, highlighting ongoing caste-based inequality in India. This incident raised significant concerns about societal intolerance, even after decades of constitutional reforms, urging a collective condemnation from all communities to uphold justice and respect in the judiciary.
Key Takeaways
- CM Siddaramaiah strongly condemned the shoe-throwing incident.
- Caste-based inequality continues to be a pressing issue in India.
- Justice B.R. Gavai stands as a symbol of meritocracy.
- Public condemnation is vital to uphold the integrity of the judiciary.
- The incident highlights the urgent need for social unity against intolerance.
Bengaluru, Oct 6 (NationPress) Karnataka Chief Minister Siddaramaiah expressed strong disapproval regarding the incident involving a shoe being thrown at Chief Justice of India (CJI) B.R. Gavai. He emphasized that caste-based inequality and intolerance continue to linger in the minds of certain individuals in the nation even after 75 years of Constitutional enforcement.
In a statement on the social media platform X, CM Siddaramaiah remarked, "I unequivocally condemn the act where a lawyer hurled a shoe at Justice B.R. Gavai, the Chief Justice of the Supreme Court, as it constitutes a grave disrespect. I call for the immediate arrest of the mischievous lawyer who insulted the Chief Justice and the judiciary, and I demand legal action be taken."
Justice B.R. Gavai, who hails from the Dalit community, has achieved the highest judicial position through merit and determination, overcoming societal challenges.
CM Siddaramaiah highlighted, "The incident today serves as proof that caste-based inequality and intolerance are still firmly entrenched in the psyche of some, despite 75 years of Constitutional implementation."
He added, "Justice B.R. Gavai is not isolated. I want to remind everyone that numerous fair-minded individuals, who uphold democracy and the Constitution, stand with him. Chief Justices are apolitical and belong to no religion. Therefore, I urge all people of diverse castes, religions, and political beliefs across the country to collectively denounce today’s incident at the Supreme Court."
CM Siddaramaiah cautioned, "We must remain vigilant as divisive figures like Rakesh Kishore have emerged in our society, promoting hatred and intolerance in the name of caste and religion. Just as some glorify the murderer Nathuram Godse as a patriot, we see some miscreants celebrating the lawyer’s misconduct. Legal measures should also be taken against such individuals, I stress."
A dramatic scene unfolded at the Supreme Court on Monday when an elderly man attempted to throw a shoe at CJI B.R. Gavai during a courtroom session.
The shoe, however, fell short of the bench, and security personnel promptly subdued the individual.
Unperturbed by the disruption, CJI Gavai addressed the court, stating, "I am the last person to be affected by such incidents," before proceedings carried on as planned.
Witnesses mentioned that the incident transpired shortly after the court began addressing the day’s first legal matter.
The man, later identified as Kishore Rakesh through a proximity card typically used by lawyers and clerks, reportedly shouted slogans like "India won't tolerate Sanatan's insult" before attempting to throw the shoe.
The motives behind the attack remain uncertain, and security agencies are currently interrogating him.
This incident followed criticism directed at CJI B.R. Gavai over a comment made during a public interest hearing regarding the restoration of a damaged idol of Lord Vishnu in Khajuraho, Madhya Pradesh.
While rejecting the plea, CJI Gavai had allegedly remarked, "Go and ask the deity himself to intervene," a statement that incited considerable backlash on social media.
In response to the uproar, CJI Gavai clarified, "I was informed that my comments were misrepresented on social media. I hold all religions in high esteem."
Point of View
We recognize the significance of this event. It highlights persistent social issues of caste-based discrimination and intolerance, which continue to challenge our constitutional values. It is imperative for us as a nation to address these issues collectively, fostering an environment of respect and equality.
NationPress
06/10/2025
Frequently Asked Questions
What was the incident involving CJI B.R. Gavai?
An elderly man attempted to throw a shoe at Chief Justice B.R. Gavai during a courtroom session, which was condemned by Karnataka's Chief Minister Siddaramaiah.
What did CM Siddaramaiah say about the incident?
CM Siddaramaiah condemned the act as disrespectful and highlighted that caste-based inequality and intolerance are still prevalent in society.
What are the implications of this incident?
This incident raises concerns about ongoing social divisions and the need for collective action against caste-based discrimination in India.
Who is Justice B.R. Gavai?
Justice B.R. Gavai is the Chief Justice of India and belongs to the Dalit community, having achieved his position through merit.
What was the public reaction to CJI Gavai's earlier remarks?
CJI Gavai faced criticism for his comments during a public interest hearing about a damaged idol, which many perceived as dismissive.
