Did K'taka Government Pass the Controversial Hate Speech Bill?
Click to start listening
Synopsis
In a tumultuous session on December 18, 2025, the Karnataka Assembly passed the controversial Hate Speech Bill without debate, sparking significant opposition. Leader of the Opposition R. Ashoka demanded it be referred to the Legislative Committee, highlighting concerns over political bias and the implications of the Bill. What does this mean for Karnataka's political landscape?
Key Takeaways
- Karnataka Assembly passed the Hate Speech Bill amid protests.
- Opposition leader R. Ashoka demanded referral to the Legislative Committee.
- The passage of the Bill was criticized for lack of debate.
- Concerns raised over potential suppression of free speech.
- Political tensions between BJP and Congress intensify.
Belagavi, Dec 18 (NationPress) In a heated session on Thursday, the Karnataka Assembly saw the controversial Karnataka Hate Speech and Hate Crimes (Prevention and Control) Bill, 2025 passed amidst uproar and without any debate from opposition members. R. Ashoka, the Leader of Opposition and a prominent figure in the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP), called for the matter to be referred to the state Legislative Committee.
During his address in the Assembly, Ashoka criticized the timing of the Bill's passage, stating, "At the very time of passing the Bill, politics of hatred is being pursued. We are demanding that the Bill be referred to the Legislative Committee. We have faith in you (the Speaker). You must convince the state government in this regard."
In response, Assembly Speaker U.T. Khader urged opposition leaders, who were protesting in the well of the House, to return to their seats.
Ashoka contended that the Speaker was biased, asserting, "They (the Congress-led government) are trying to take the state back to the 1980s and impose an Emergency-like situation. Since our request has not been considered, we will stage a walkout." Following this statement, BJP and JD-S members exited the Assembly, chanting slogans like "Speaker one side."
Speaker Khader remarked that he had waited for nearly 15 minutes for the opposition to settle down, questioning, "I repeatedly asked MLAs to calm down. Don't you want to respect the Speaker's words?"
State Minister for Law and Parliamentary Affairs H.K. Patil addressed the opposition, stating, "Even if it is a question of self-respect, the rules of the House should not be violated. The Bill has already been passed. The Leader of the Opposition should clarify what is expected now. Since it has already been passed in the House, the matter should end here. Whenever the Opposition leader or the Chief Minister speaks, members should not disturb them. That discipline must be maintained."
Earlier on Thursday, the Karnataka Assembly passed the contentious Bill amidst chaos and without a debate involving opposition members.
In a dramatic display of dissent, R. Ashoka tore a copy of the Bill on the Assembly floor, emphasizing his strong objections. Amidst the uproar from BJP and JD-S MLAs, Speaker Khader conducted a vote and announced the Bill's passage.
The BJP members voiced their discontent, alleging that the Assembly Speaker's actions were inappropriate and detrimental to parliamentary standards.
Ashoka reiterated his stance, stating, "I have not completed my speech on the Hate Speech Regulation Bill. We are prepared to speak on the Bill. Curtailing the rights of Opposition members is not a good tradition. Please rethink and allow the discussion to take place."
Point of View
It’s crucial to observe the evolving political landscape in Karnataka. The passage of the Hate Speech Bill without proper debate raises significant questions about governance and democratic norms. While the ruling party asserts the necessity of such legislation, the opposition's outcry highlights concerns over freedom of speech and potential misuse. An unbiased analysis reveals the need for a balanced approach to legislation that respects both security and civil liberties.
NationPress
20/12/2025
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the Karnataka Hate Speech Bill?
The Karnataka Hate Speech and Hate Crimes (Prevention and Control) Bill, 2025 aims to address issues related to hate speech and hate crimes in the state.
Why did the BJP walk out of the Assembly?
The BJP walked out in protest against the passage of the Bill without debate and their demand for it to be referred to the Legislative Committee was ignored.
What were the objections raised by the opposition?
The opposition, particularly the BJP, objected to the manner of the Bill's passage, claiming it was politically motivated and detrimental to democratic processes.
What are the implications of this Bill?
The Bill's implications could affect freedom of speech, the balance of power in the Assembly, and the political climate in Karnataka.
Who is R. Ashoka?
R. Ashoka is the Leader of Opposition in the Karnataka Assembly and a senior BJP leader, known for his vocal criticism of the ruling government.
