MP Congress accuses BJP of anti-tribal mindset over MLA's 'no Adivasis' remark

Share:
Audio Loading voice…
MP Congress accuses BJP of anti-tribal mindset over MLA's 'no Adivasis' remark

Synopsis

On the day meant to honour India's tribal heritage, a BJP MLA in Guna claimed 'there are no Adivasis in the country' — and the Congress has seized on the irony. With MP's tribal constituencies in perpetual political play, Pannalal Shakya's remarks at a Janjatiya Gaurav Diwas event have handed the opposition a pointed question: can the BJP celebrate Tribal Pride Day while one of its own denies tribal identity?

Key Takeaways

BJP Guna MLA Pannalal Shakya claimed 'there are no Adivasis in the country' at a Janjatiya Gaurav Diwas event in Guna on Sunday, 15 November 2026 .
MP Leader of Opposition Umang Singhar accused the BJP of an anti-tribal mindset and demanded state action against Shakya.
Singhar said the tribal community was not a 'prop' for the BJP's political posturing, addressing his remarks to Chief Minister Mohan Yadav .
This is Shakya's second major controversy in 2026 — he earlier faced backlash in August over remarks about Goddess Sita.
The BJP is yet to issue an official response to the Congress's demands for action.

Madhya Pradesh Leader of Opposition Umang Singhar on 16 November 2026 accused the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) of harbouring an anti-tribal mindset, following controversial remarks by Guna MLA Pannalal Shakya, who claimed there were 'no Adivasis in the country' at a district-level event in Guna. The remarks, made during a Janjatiya Gaurav Diwas programme, have triggered a sharp political row in Madhya Pradesh.

What the MLA Said

Shakya made the remarks while addressing a district-level function in Guna on Sunday to mark Janjatiya Gaurav Diwas and the birth anniversary of tribal icon Birsa Munda. Questioning the classification of Indian society into identity-based categories, the BJP legislator argued that people living in hills were called 'Girvasis', those in forests 'Vanvasis', village residents 'Gramvasis', and city dwellers 'Nagarvasis' — asserting that the term 'Adivasi' had no legitimate basis.

Shakya also questioned the use of terms such as Adivasi, Puravasi, Janjati and Scheduled Caste, as well as the classification of people into forward and backward categories. He invoked religious traditions, citing the practice of worshipping Lord Ganesha at ceremonies, to argue for a broader social unity.

Congress Hits Back

Singhar, himself a tribal Congress leader, said Shakya's remarks had 'exposed' the BJP's true attitude towards the tribal community. He drew a pointed contrast between the party's public celebration of Tribal Pride Day and what he called 'hollow politics' conducted in the name of tribal welfare.

'On one hand, the BJP pretends to celebrate Tribal Pride Day and indulges in hollow politics in the name of the tribal community. On the other hand, its MLA Pannalal Shakya, by claiming that there are no tribals in the country, is outright denying the very identity of the tribal community,' Singhar said.

Addressing Chief Minister Mohan Yadav directly, the Leader of Opposition said the tribal community was not a 'prop' for political posturing but a community that stood firmly for its rights, dignity and identity. He demanded that the state government clarify when it would take strict action against the MLA.

A Pattern of Controversy

This is not the first time Shakya has drawn criticism for his public remarks. On 5 August this year, the BJP legislator faced backlash for comments referencing Goddess Sita while speaking about the consequences of coveting another man's wife. While citing the episode of Ravana's abduction from the Ramayana, Shakya used the expression 'maut ka samaan' (cause of death) for the goddess, drawing widespread objections over his choice of words.

Political Stakes in a Tribal-Heavy State

Madhya Pradesh has a substantial tribal population, and both the BJP and Congress have historically contested tribal constituencies fiercely. Janjatiya Gaurav Diwas, observed on 15 November to mark Birsa Munda's birth anniversary, was institutionalised by the Centre as a federal initiative to consolidate tribal sentiment. Critics argue that Shakya's remarks on the very day meant to honour tribal identity represent a significant political misstep. The BJP is yet to issue an official response to Singhar's demands.

Point of View

The Centre's own initiative to signal tribal respect — making the optics for the BJP difficult to manage. The deeper issue is that questioning the constitutional category of Scheduled Tribes is not merely a rhetorical misstep; it carries legal and political weight in a state where tribal seats have swung governments. The BJP's silence so far is itself a signal — distancing without disciplining risks pleasing neither camp. For the Congress, Singhar's tribal identity lends the attack credibility that a non-tribal leader could not have mustered.
NationPress
16 Nov 2026

Frequently Asked Questions

What did BJP MLA Pannalal Shakya say about Adivasis?
Shakya claimed that there were 'no Adivasis in the country' during a Janjatiya Gaurav Diwas event in Guna on 15 November 2026. He argued that people are defined by where they live — hills, forests, villages or cities — and questioned the use of terms like Adivasi, Janjati and Scheduled Caste.
Why is the Congress attacking BJP over these remarks?
The Congress argues that the remarks expose a contradiction at the heart of BJP politics: publicly celebrating Tribal Pride Day while one of its own MLAs denies the very existence and identity of the tribal community. Leader of Opposition Umang Singhar, himself a tribal leader, has demanded that Chief Minister Mohan Yadav take strict action against Shakya.
What is Janjatiya Gaurav Diwas and why does it matter here?
Janjatiya Gaurav Diwas is observed on 15 November each year to mark the birth anniversary of tribal icon Birsa Munda and was institutionalised by the Centre to honour tribal heritage. The timing of Shakya's remarks — made at an event marking this very day — has made the controversy politically acute.
Has Pannalal Shakya been controversial before?
Yes. On 5 August 2026, Shakya faced criticism for using the expression 'maut ka samaan' (cause of death) while referencing Goddess Sita during a speech about Ravana's abduction from the Ramayana, drawing objections over his choice of words.
What action has been demanded and has the BJP responded?
Congress Leader of Opposition Umang Singhar has demanded that the Madhya Pradesh government clarify when it will take strict action against Shakya for questioning the identity of the tribal community. As of the time of this report, the BJP has not issued an official response.
Nation Press
The Trail

Connected Dots

Tracing the thread behind this story — newest first.

8 Dots
  1. Latest 14 hours ago
  2. 18 hours ago
  3. 20 hours ago
  4. Yesterday
  5. Yesterday
  6. 2 days ago
  7. 2 days ago
  8. 1 week ago
Google Prefer NP
On Google