Did Nishikant Dubey Just Expose Rahul Gandhi Over the 2006 US Hyde Act?
Click to start listening
Synopsis
Nishikant Dubey's recent remarks highlight the implications of the 2006 US Hyde Act on India's sovereignty. His sharp critique of Rahul Gandhi raises questions about historical accountability and the influence of foreign power in Indian politics. This article delves into the impact of the Act and the political dynamics surrounding it.
Key Takeaways
- Nishikant Dubey challenges Rahul Gandhi regarding the implications of the Hyde Act.
- The Act is perceived as a limitation on India's sovereignty.
- Historical events from the 1995 nuclear test are highlighted.
- International pressure has influenced Indian political decisions.
- Current leadership promotes a narrative of assertiveness against foreign influence.
New Delhi, June 12 (NationPress) BJP Lok Sabha member Nishikant Dubey has made a pointed critique of the Congress party and its leader Rahul Gandhi, alleging critical insights regarding the Henry J. Hyde United States-India Peaceful Atomic Energy Act of 2006. In a post on his X handle directed towards the Leader of the Opposition (LoP) in the Lok Sabha, Dubey urged Gandhi to examine this legislation, which he claims has effectively rendered India and its citizens subservient.
In his post, which is in Hindi and loosely translated, he stated: “...We became subjugated under this American law until 2006/2008... The United States can scrutinize nearly all citizens of our nation and our strategic nuclear facilities whenever it pleases. Can India reciprocate and inspect the US in a similar manner?”
Dubey further probes Congress about the perceived “pressures” in 2008.
“What was the American influence that led to the fracturing of parties and the buying of MPs to pass this legislation in 2008?”
He emphasized that if India is to maintain its sovereignty, then “how can legislation from the US Congress apply to India?”
Dubey reminded Rahul Gandhi that he was the General Secretary of the Congress during the time of this deal. “In the end, Rahul Baba, you were the General Secretary of the Congress back then.”
On Wednesday, Dubey presented declassified documents and accused the Congress government of yielding to US pressure, which resulted in the cancellation of a planned nuclear test in 1995.
He asserted that apprehensions about American retaliation influenced the decision, despite the initial agreement by then Prime Minister P.V. Narasimha Rao.
“Reflect on the history of how Rahul Gandhi, whom I refer to as 'Rahul Baba,' is intimidated by the United States,” Dubey remarked in his post on X.
“In 1995, Prime Minister Narasimha Rao intended to conduct a nuclear test, but sensitive information was allegedly leaked to the United States by a senior minister or government official.”
Dubey further claimed that this leak triggered direct intervention from the US President, who reportedly reached out to the Principal Secretary of the Indian Prime Minister via an urgent overnight telegram to request a meeting.
“The Charge d’Affairs was ordered to facilitate a meeting with PMO Principal Secretary Varma for Ambassador Wisner upon his return to New Delhi,” shared Dubey, referencing pertinent portions of the classified document. He argued that this external pressure compelled the Congress government to abandon the test due to fear.
“In contrast, when the BJP was in power under Atal Bihari Vajpayee in 1998, we conducted nuclear tests in Pokhran despite facing international sanctions and diplomatic pressure,” he added.
“Prime Minister Modi has exhibited similar determination in recent years. Rahul Gandhi should delve into history and reflect,” Dubey concluded.
Point of View
It's essential to critically assess the assertions made by Nishikant Dubey regarding the 2006 US Hyde Act. While highlighting historical events, we must acknowledge the complexities of international relations and the implications of such legislation on India's political landscape. Objective dialogue is crucial for a comprehensive understanding of our nation's sovereignty.
NationPress
16/06/2025
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the US Hyde Act?
The US Hyde Act, enacted in 2006, governs the civil nuclear cooperation between the United States and India, establishing guidelines and conditions for nuclear engagement.
Why did Nishikant Dubey criticize Rahul Gandhi?
Nishikant Dubey criticized Rahul Gandhi for his role during the enactment of the Hyde Act, suggesting that it compromised India's sovereignty.
What historical context did Dubey provide?
Dubey referenced the cancellation of a nuclear test in 1995 due to alleged US pressure and questioned the integrity of Congress during that period.
What was the reaction to Dubey's claims?
Dubey's remarks have sparked debates about foreign influence in Indian politics and the responsibilities of past leaders.
How does the current government view the Hyde Act?
The current government, led by Prime Minister Modi, maintains a strong stance on national sovereignty and asserts independence from foreign pressures.
