Has Rajasthan HC summoned Chief Secy and Education Secy over mid-session teacher transfers?
Click to start listening
Synopsis
In a recent ruling, the Rajasthan High Court's Justice Sameer Jain expressed grave concerns about the mass transfer of teachers during the academic year. With board exams looming, the court summoned key education officials to explain their controversial decisions. Will this lead to a more structured policy on teacher transfers?
Key Takeaways
- Rajasthan High Court raises concerns over mid-session teacher transfers.
- Over 12,000 teachers transferred since August 3.
- Board examinations scheduled for February 12 are approaching.
- Traditional transfer policy is from July 1 each year.
- Government criticized for lack of transparency in transfer policy.
Jaipur, Jan 21 (NationPress) The Rajasthan High Court expressed significant alarm regarding the extensive transfer of teachers during the academic session, particularly with board examinations set to commence in under 20 days.
Justice Sameer Jain’s bench interrogated the state government about the rationale behind such transfers and ordered the Chief Secretary and the Principal Secretary of Education to appear before the court on January 23 to clarify their actions.
This ruling was made in response to a petition lodged by Maina Garhwal and Mahesh Kumar.
Their attorney, advocate Sandeep Kalwaniya, informed the bench that traditionally, transfers in government schools occur starting from July 1 each year. However, since August 3, the government has executed transfers of over 12,000 senior teachers, school lecturers, and principals.
The petitioners highlighted that while transfers are officially prohibited in the state, the government has been granting special permissions for mass transfers without a clearly defined or transparent policy.
The court was informed that this practice has led to considerable disruption in schools, adversely affecting both teachers and students.
As board examinations are approaching on February 12, the petitioners contended that relocating teachers and principals during this pivotal period is detrimental to academic continuity and student preparation for examinations.
The High Court also referenced its prior reportable order, which raised critical concerns regarding the absence of a comprehensive transfer policy in Rajasthan, the practice of mid-session transfers, and the operations of the Rajasthan Civil Services Appellate Tribunal (RCAT).
In its remarks, the court acknowledged that while many states lack a structured transfer policy for government employees, including educators, it stressed that the state must uphold good governance in accordance with constitutional standards.
The court's summons indicates a closer judicial examination of the government's transfer decisions and their ramifications on the education system.
Point of View
The recent summons by the Rajasthan High Court highlights a critical issue within the state's educational system. The apparent lack of a transparent transfer policy raises questions about governance and its impact on students during crucial examination periods. It is essential for states to prioritize stability in education to ensure that students can perform to the best of their abilities.
NationPress
21/01/2026
Frequently Asked Questions
Why did the Rajasthan High Court summon the Chief Secretary and Education Secretary?
The court summoned these officials to explain the rationale behind large-scale teacher transfers during the academic session, particularly with exams approaching.
What is the traditional timeframe for teacher transfers in Rajasthan?
Traditionally, teacher transfers in Rajasthan are conducted starting from July 1 each year.
How many teachers have been transferred since August 3?
Over 12,000 senior teachers, school lecturers, and principals have been transferred since August 3.
What concerns did the petitioners raise?
The petitioners highlighted that the government's mass transfers are causing disruptions in schools, affecting the academic preparation of students.
What is the significance of the board examinations scheduled for February 12?
The board examinations are crucial for students' academic progress, making the timing of teacher transfers particularly concerning.
