Siraj's omission shocks Shastri, Gavaskar, Rahane and DK in 1st Test vs NZ
Synopsis
Key Takeaways
Mohammed Siraj's absence from India's playing eleven for the first Test against New Zealand at Basin Reserve, Wellington, on 19 November drew sharp criticism from some of Indian cricket's most respected voices, with former head coach Ravi Shastri, batting legend Sunil Gavaskar, ex-captain Ajinkya Rahane, and former wicketkeeper-batter Dinesh Karthik all questioning the selection call on a pitch that visibly rewarded seam movement.
Shastri Breaks Silence on X
Shastri was among the first to publicly raise the alarm, posting directly on X: 'Hope India bounce back strongly. But if pace, skill and seam movement were the criteria, and 140 clicks was hard to come by, one has to ask the question. Where was MOHD SIRAJ? Experience, aggression and the ability to make things happen with the ball. Surely that counts for something!'
The numbers support his case. Siraj is currently India's leading wicket-taker in the ongoing World Test Championship (WTC) cycle, having claimed 43 wickets at an average of 26.81. Ravindra Jadeja — also left out of the eleven — is next on the list with 33 wickets. Jadeja has also been a reliable lower-order contributor, ranked third among India's run-scorers with 790 runs at an average of 60.76, including two hundreds and six fifties.
How the Match Unfolded — and Why the Omission Hurt
India's bowlers had New Zealand under pressure at 70 for 5, but were unable to press home the advantage. Henry Nicholls (113 not out) and Glenn Phillips (94 not out) then forged an unbroken 173-run partnership, taking the hosts to 243 for 5 at stumps on Day 1 — precisely the kind of moment, critics argued, that demanded a bowler with Siraj's tenacity and ability to manufacture breakthroughs.
Gavaskar, Rahane Voice Concerns on Air
On Sony Sports Network's broadcast, Sunil Gavaskar expressed his surprise at the exclusion. 'I think the signs were there when he was drafted into the 50-overs side and only played the last game. Actually, when he played the last game, I thought that they were prepping him for the match over here. But not to see his name in the playing eleven is a surprise, is a surprise because I don't think he's let India down, never let India down,' Gavaskar said.
He added: 'And there's nothing that has gone wrong with his bowling. His rhythm is good. We've seen him in between whatever cricket he's played, he's been fine. Why he's not been picked is something that I don't know.'
Speaking on the Hindi feed, Rahane was equally forthright: 'I might talk for an hour on this topic. Mohammed Siraj not playing is a surprising decision. You have an experienced bowler. Jasprit Bumrah has returned. When you have Bumrah and Siraj, and Prasidh Krishna has recently started to do well, and you have made one of those quality fast bowlers sit out.'
Rahane also flagged the choice to field Washington Sundar ahead of Jadeja. 'I understand Ravindra Jadeja does not get that much help in bowling in overseas conditions, but check out his batting average, his contributions, and consistency. It's not understandable. You are in the race for the WTC final and are going to play only two matches here. So play your best team,' he said.
Dinesh Karthik and Wasim Jaffer Add Their Voices
Dinesh Karthik said the omission was the single biggest surprise of the selection. 'What shocked me was Siraj not being there. I didn't see that coming. I genuinely thought it was going to be Bumrah and Siraj,' he said. While acknowledging Siraj's modest recent returns — five wickets in three Tests played in 2024 — Karthik attributed them to unhelpful subcontinental conditions. He pointed to Siraj picking up 23 wickets in England when leading the attack in Bumrah's absence, calling him 'a workhorse and an absolute champion when it comes to the attitude that's required in Test matches.'
Former opener Wasim Jaffer posted on X that while he could follow the logic of picking Sundar over Jadeja given New Zealand's left-handers, Siraj's exclusion was harder to defend. 'The man who single-handedly levelled the England series and is India's leading wicket-taker in this WTC cycle doesn't find a place, even in favourable conditions? India are already missing him on Day 1. This is Siraj territory… Very difficult to digest!' Jaffer wrote.
What It Means for India's WTC Ambitions
India have only two Tests in New Zealand this cycle, making each match critical for their WTC final qualification prospects. The selection debate goes beyond individual sentiment — the choice to leave out the team's leading WTC wicket-taker in conditions typically suited to his strengths is a call that will face intense scrutiny depending on how the rest of the match unfolds. The team management has not publicly explained the rationale for Siraj's omission.