Did Ex-J&K DGP Criticize National Conference MLA for Comments on National Emblem?
Click to start listening
Synopsis
The clash between former J&K DGP S.P. Vaid and NC MLA Tanvir Sadiq highlights the sensitive intersection of religion and national identity at Hazratbal shrine, a revered site for Muslims. As tensions rise, the implications of their statements may resonate beyond the local community.
Key Takeaways
- S.P. Vaid warned against misrepresenting national symbols.
- The national emblem is integral to India’s Constitution.
- Religious and national identities can clash, especially in sensitive regions.
- Vandalism at religious sites can exacerbate community tensions.
- Major gatherings like Eid-e-Milad reflect the rich cultural fabric of Kashmir.
Srinagar, Sep 5 (NationPress) Former Jammu and Kashmir Director General of Police S.P. Vaid strongly responded to remarks made by the ruling National Conference (NC) MLA and party spokesperson Tanvir Sadiq regarding the national emblem, which is engraved on an inauguration stone at Srinagar’s Hazratbal shrine.
Earlier on Friday, Tanvir Sadiq, who represents the Zadibal Assembly constituency, stated on X: “While I am not an expert in religious matters, in Islam, idol worship is considered strictly forbidden — one of the gravest sins. The foundation of our faith rests on Tawheed.
“The placement of a sculpted figure at the esteemed Hazratbal Dargah contradicts this fundamental belief. Sacred spaces should embody the purity of Tawheed and nothing else.”
S.P. Vaid took to X to criticize Tanvir Sadiq for his remarks regarding the national emblem, stating, “Tread carefully, Tanvir. Choose your words prudently. The National Emblem is embedded in India’s Constitution, the very foundation of the rights we all enjoy.
“Even the currency you handle features it. There is no idol worship involved. Misrepresenting facts only nurtures radical ideologies in Kashmir.”
In another incident, Darakhshan Andrabi, chairperson of the Waqf board, held a press conference demanding strict actions against individuals who vandalized the inauguration stone outside the Hazratbal shrine by smashing it to deface the national emblem.
The inauguration stone had been established two days prior, coinciding with the internal decoration and renovation of the shrine, funded by the Waqf board at a cost of crores of Rupees.
During the inauguration ceremony, Darakhshan Andrabi stated that the renovation was financed through the Waqf board’s own resources without external borrowing.
On Friday, thousands of devoted Muslims congregated at the Hazratbal shrine to engage in prayer and reflection in honor of the birthday of the Prophet of Islam (Eid-e-Milad).
This yearly event marks the largest assembly of Muslims at the Hazratbal shrine to celebrate the Prophet's birthday.
Point of View
It's crucial to understand that discussions surrounding religious sentiments and national symbols can evoke strong reactions. S.P. Vaid's comments underscore the importance of thoughtful dialogue in a region where identity and faith often intersect. Upholding constitutional values is essential for maintaining harmony and understanding in diverse societies.
NationPress
05/09/2025
Frequently Asked Questions
What triggered the criticism from S.P. Vaid?
S.P. Vaid criticized NC MLA Tanvir Sadiq's remarks about idol worship in relation to the national emblem at Hazratbal shrine, emphasizing the importance of the emblem in the Indian Constitution.
What is the significance of the Hazratbal shrine?
The Hazratbal shrine is a revered Islamic site in Srinagar, attracting thousands of devotees, especially during significant religious events like Eid-e-Milad.
What actions were taken regarding the vandalism of the inauguration stone?
Darakhshan Andrabi, chairperson of the Waqf board, called for strict punishment against individuals who vandalized the inauguration stone at the Hazratbal shrine.
How does this incident reflect larger societal issues?
This incident highlights ongoing tensions in Kashmir regarding religious identity and national symbols, which can fuel radical mindsets and affect communal harmony.
What was the purpose of the renovation at the Hazratbal shrine?
The renovation, funded by the Waqf board, aimed to enhance the shrine's internal decor, reflecting its significance as a spiritual site.
