Did the High Court Permit Former Army Personnel to Protest Against Bengal CM’s Remarks?
Click to start listening
Synopsis
In a significant ruling, the Calcutta High Court has allowed former defence personnel to protest against derogatory comments made by West Bengal's Chief Minister, Mamata Banerjee. The protest is set for Thursday, aiming to address concerns over respect for the Indian Armed Forces. This development highlights ongoing tensions between the government and military personnel.
Key Takeaways
- The Calcutta High Court has authorized a protest by former defence personnel.
- The protest aims to address remarks deemed derogatory to the armed forces.
- Attendance is limited to 225 individuals to ensure safety.
- No political leaders from the BJP are allowed during the protest.
- The event highlights ongoing tensions between the military and state politics.
Kolkata, Sep 10 (NationPress) A single-judge bench of the Calcutta High Court granted permission on Wednesday for a gathering of former defence personnel to stage a protest in Kolkata on Thursday. This demonstration is in response to remarks made by West Bengal Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee, which were perceived as disrespectful towards the Indian Armed Forces.
After their initial request for a protest on Tuesday was denied by the police, these former defence officials, residing in West Bengal, sought the intervention of Justice Tirthankar Ghosh at the Calcutta High Court.
During the hearing on Wednesday, Justice Ghosh permitted the protest to take place at the base of the statue of Mahatma Gandhi in central Kolkata, limiting the gathering to a maximum of 225 individuals.
The judge specified that the protest would be allowed from 12 noon to 5 p.m., and made it clear that no leaders or activists from the BJP would be permitted to attend the demonstration during this timeframe.
Last month, Indian Army personnel dismantled a stage for a Trinamool Congress demonstration located in the Maidan area, which falls under the jurisdiction of the Army’s Eastern Command. The Army argued that although permission for the demonstration was granted for just two days, the ruling party failed to dismantle it for nearly a month despite several reminders.
As the Army personnel were carrying out the dismantling, the Chief Minister arrived at the scene. Following her arrival, the defence personnel completed their work and departed.
However, the Chief Minister and her party presented a contrasting narrative, claiming that around 200 Army personnel fled the area upon her arrival. She stated, “I inquired why they were running away. I told them they were my friends. Their actions were influenced by the BJP and directives from Delhi.”
A group of former defence personnel vehemently opposed the Chief Minister's comments. Their organization sought police permission to protest at the foot of the Gandhi statue, but an alternative location was proposed by the state. Subsequently, they opted to approach the Calcutta High Court for resolution.
Point of View
It is crucial to remain impartial while acknowledging the concerns of both the former defence personnel and the government. This situation exemplifies the delicate balance between political expression and respect for the military, urging a dialogue that honors the sacrifices of our armed forces.
NationPress
27/10/2025
Frequently Asked Questions
Why was the protest organized?
The protest was organized in response to derogatory remarks made by Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee about the Indian Armed Forces.
Where is the protest taking place?
The protest is scheduled to take place at the statue of Mahatma Gandhi in central Kolkata.
What was the court's ruling regarding the protest?
The Calcutta High Court allowed the protest with a cap of 225 participants and set the timing from 12 noon to 5 p.m.
What restrictions were placed on the protest?
No BJP leaders or activists will be allowed to attend the protest during the specified time.
What sparked the conflict between the Army and the Chief Minister?
The conflict arose when the Indian Army dismantled a Trinamool Congress demonstration stage, leading to conflicting narratives between the Chief Minister and the military.
