Why Did the SC Reject the Plea Against Telangana's BC Reservation Order?

Click to start listening
Why Did the SC Reject the Plea Against Telangana's BC Reservation Order?

Synopsis

The Supreme Court's recent decision not to hear a plea against Telangana's BC reservation order raises questions about judicial intervention in state policies. With elections approaching, the state's commitment to 42% reservation for Backward Classes remains steadfast, showcasing the ongoing tension between legal frameworks and political commitments.

Key Takeaways

  • Supreme Court dismisses plea against Telangana's reservation order.
  • Telangana government pledges 42% reservation for BCs in local governance.
  • Legal disputes concerning reservations are ongoing.
  • Local body elections are set for October-November.
  • State's commitment to BC representation remains strong.

New Delhi, Oct 6 (NationPress) The Supreme Court has, on Monday, declined to accept a writ petition that challenged the Telangana government's directive to allocate 42 percent reservation to the Backward Classes (BCs) in rural local bodies across the state.

A bench consisting of Justice Vikram Nath and Justice Sandeep Mehta chose not to hear the petition, noting that the issue is already under consideration by the Telangana High Court, and dismissed the petition submitted by Vanga Gopal Reddy.

Senior attorneys Abhishek Manu Singhvi, Siddharth Dave, and A.D.N. Rao, representing the state government, informed the bench that there are two existing petitions pending in the High Court.

The bench inquired as to why the petitioner opted to file under Article 32.

When the petitioner pointed out that the High Court had not issued a stay, the bench questioned how the Supreme Court could be approached when the High Court had denied the stay.

Deputy Chief Minister Mallu Bhatti Vikramarka, accompanied by Ministers Ponnam Prabhakar and Vakiti Srihari, expressed satisfaction with the Supreme Court's ruling.

Speaking to the media outside the Supreme Court, the Deputy Chief Minister affirmed the state government's commitment to provide 42 percent reservation for BCs in education, employment, and local governance.

He stated that the state government is poised to implement the BC reservation in local body elections.

"With local body elections underway, the state government has passed a Bill and issued a government order (GO). We are steadfast in our position and will advocate for it," he remarked.

The Deputy Chief Minister and state Ministers had previously conferred with Manu Singhvi, who is also a member of the Rajya Sabha representing Telangana, and Dave.

Government attorney Shravan Kumar and Congress BC Cell Chairman Anil Jaihind were also in attendance.

The officials informed the lawyers that the GO for 42 percent reservations for BCs in local bodies was issued in accordance with the guidelines set by the Supreme Court.

They emphasized that the GO was enacted following a caste survey, the collection of empirical data on BCs, the establishment of a dedicated BC Commission, and an expert group’s analysis of the caste survey findings.

The State Election Commission recently announced the schedule for rural local body elections, which will take place in five phases during October and November this year.

Point of View

It is imperative to recognize the delicate balance between judicial scrutiny and state legislative actions. The Supreme Court's decision underscores its respect for ongoing legal processes, while the Telangana government's commitment to BC reservations reflects a broader socio-political strategy aimed at inclusivity. Ultimately, this case exemplifies the dynamic interplay of law and governance in contemporary India.
NationPress
06/10/2025

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the Supreme Court's recent decision regarding BC reservations in Telangana?
The Supreme Court declined to admit a petition challenging the Telangana government's order providing 42% reservation to Backward Classes in rural bodies, citing the matter is pending in the Telangana High Court.
What was the basis for the Telangana government's 42% reservation policy?
The policy was established following a caste survey, empirical data collection, and adherence to guidelines set by the Supreme Court.
When will the local body elections be held in Telangana?
The elections for rural local bodies are scheduled to occur in five phases during October and November of this year.
Nation Press