Is Khawaja Asif Navigating Pakistan's Dilemma Between the Eagle and the Dragon?

Click to start listening
Is Khawaja Asif Navigating Pakistan's Dilemma Between the Eagle and the Dragon?

Synopsis

As Pakistan's Defence Minister Khawaja Asif reveals closer ties with China than the US, the nation finds itself at a crossroads amid escalating diplomatic tensions. While attempting to navigate these challenges, questions arise about the true nature of Pakistan's relationships with both powers.

Key Takeaways

  • Khawaja Asif admits closer ties with China.
  • Pakistan is navigating economic instability.
  • US-Pakistan relations are under scrutiny amid rising tensions.
  • Beijing's role in Pakistan's defense is increasing.
  • Strategic decisions will shape Pakistan's future.

New Delhi, Sep 30 (NationPress) Pakistan's Defence Minister Khawaja Asif has candidly acknowledged Islamabad's closer alignment with Beijing than with Washington, asserting that the two will perpetually be in conflict. This revelation arises at a moment when his leaders are attempting to cultivate a relationship with the White House.

In a revealing exchange with British-American journalist Mehdi Hasan, Asif conceded that "defence cooperation is increasing with China" due to the "unreliability of other sources, such as the US." This discussion took place while he was in New York for the United Nations General Assembly (UNGA) session. Ironically, Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif was simultaneously attending a meeting with US President Donald Trump in Washington.

Asif's defense of Pakistan's distinct governance model, which intertwines political and military leadership, is further complicated by the timing of a White House meeting attended by Sharif and Gen Asim Munir on September 25. Their 80-minute discussion was preceded by a 30-minute wait while Trump managed other obligations.

As the Defence Minister, Asif highlighted Pakistan's "time-tested relationship" with China dating back to the 1950s, emphasizing Beijing's reliability as a supplier of "arms and other necessities." His assertion that Pakistan's "strategic future can’t be with both (the US and China)" raises critical questions.

Is Pakistan genuinely being "flirtatious" with the US, as Asif suggested during the interview, without any clear agenda? Or was the White House summoning his leaders for an undisclosed purpose?

Regardless, Pakistan is navigating severe economic turmoil and unrest in tribal regions while caught in the diplomatic crossfire between the US and China.

Amid rising domestic challenges, the Sharif administration, like its predecessors, has sought to strengthen ties with Washington, particularly in security, while simultaneously renewing its partnership with China, with which it shares a border.

Asif's previous criticisms of the "Western world" for their involvement in covert operations against the Soviet Union during the Afghan conflict may indicate a shift towards China.

While recognizing US support in times past, such as the deployment of the Seventh Fleet during the Bangladesh Liberation War in 1971, he overlooks the rapid military-diplomatic maneuvers by India and the former USSR that undermined that support.

Moreover, he has disregarded China's strong reaction to the deaths of its citizens involved in infrastructure projects in Pakistan, which has led to indications that Beijing might withdraw funding from significant connectivity initiatives.

In a prior interview, Asif remarked on how the US abandoned Pakistan after the first Afghan War against the Soviet occupation, stating, "we were left high and dry." He lamented that Pakistan continues to bear the burden of consequences from Afghanistan's tumultuous history.

As Pakistan's economy falters, the West has facilitated aid through global organizations, while China has been heavily investing, creating a scenario where Islamabad risks falling into a debt trap.

As Asif previously stated, "All we have is a geographical location, which is strategic, attracting not always favorable elements that can render us more vulnerable."

Point of View

I affirm that Pakistan must navigate its relationships with both the US and China with a clear strategy. While the urgency of economic stability is paramount, it is essential to maintain an independent foreign policy that prioritizes national interests above external pressures.
NationPress
30/09/2025

Frequently Asked Questions

What prompted Khawaja Asif's comments about China and the US?
His comments stem from increasing defense cooperation with China due to perceived unreliability from the US.
How does Pakistan balance its relationships with China and the US?
Pakistan seeks a dual approach, engaging with both nations while addressing domestic challenges.
What historical context influences Pakistan's relationship with these powers?
Pakistan's history includes significant US support during the Cold War, contrasted with a growing dependency on China in recent years.
Nation Press