Pakistan media faces 97 violations in 2026, 'lawfare' replaces physical attacks
Synopsis
Key Takeaways
Pakistan's media environment is under sustained pressure through legal mechanisms that inflict damage without always resorting to physical violence, according to Freedom Network's Impunity Report 2026. The annual report, titled 'From Violence to Lawfare: Process as Punishment for Journalists', documents 97 violations against journalists and media professionals between October 2025 and August 2026, describing the country as a 'deeply hostile environment' for press freedom despite a nominal decline in recorded incidents.
Scale and Nature of Violations
The 97 documented violations between October 2025 and August 2026 represent a drop from the 142 cases logged in the preceding cycle. However, the report cautions that fewer violations do not equate to greater safety. The breakdown included one work-related killing, three attempted assassinations, 18 threats of murder or harm, 13 legal actions, 32 threats of legal action, and 11 physical assaults — averaging roughly 10 cases per month across the country.
The report was authored by journalist Adnan Rehmat and Freedom Network Executive Director Iqbal Khattak, with technical assistance from International Media Support (IMS).
How 'Lawfare' Works Against Journalists
The report identifies the National Cyber Crime Investigation Agency (NCCIA) and the Prevention of Electronic Crimes Act (PECA) as central instruments in what it describes as a 'legal siege' of online journalism in Pakistan. According to the report's analysis, PECA-related cases against journalists follow a recurring pattern: complaint, notice or inquiry, court appearance, FIR registration, arrest, bail, and eventual relief, apology, or unresolved prosecution.
Allegations involving alleged defamation, false information, harassment, or reputational harm are, according to Freedom Network, 'repeatedly channelled through cybercrime procedures' — including in cases where reporting concerns public expenditure, corruption, or official conduct.
Notably, digital and independent journalists were targeted most often. Victims or their families reportedly identified government authorities and officials as alleged instigators in nearly two-thirds of documented cases.
The Paradox of Protective Laws
Pakistan has enacted legislation ostensibly designed to protect journalists, yet Freedom Network's findings raise pointed questions about its effectiveness. Laws meant to shield media professionals from online offences coexist, the report notes, with credible allegations that the same cybercrime framework is being wielded to pressurise reporters. The bodies responsible for safeguarding media professionals have, according to the report, struggled to demonstrate their mandate in practice.
This comes amid a broader global pattern in which authoritarian and semi-authoritarian states have increasingly substituted direct physical intimidation with procedural harassment — a tactic that is harder to document and easier to sustain without attracting international condemnation.
The Chilling Effect on Public Interest Reporting
The report draws a sharp distinction between legal accountability and legal weaponisation. 'The central concern is not whether journalists should be above the law,' it notes. 'It is whether the law is being applied without discrimination and whether those who investigate wrongdoing can do so without facing disproportionate retaliation.'
Prolonged legal proceedings impose compounding financial, professional, and psychological costs on journalists even when no conviction ultimately follows. A summons, a device seizure, or a repeated court appearance can effectively silence a reporter without requiring a single guilty verdict. The report argues that when legal proceedings become a tool for discouraging scrutiny, the damage extends beyond individual journalists and narrows the space for public-interest reporting at large.
With accountability for violations remaining largely unresolved, the question of whether Pakistan's protective legal architecture will be reformed — or further subverted — is expected to remain a defining issue for press freedom advocates in the region.