Badrinath Dham donation theft: 32 days of CCTV footage missing from probe
Synopsis
Key Takeaways
A critical gap has emerged in the investigation into the Shri Badrinath Dham donation theft case: 32 days of CCTV footage, considered vital evidence, are reportedly missing, sources confirmed on 13 June. The development marks a significant setback for investigators probing the alleged misappropriation of offerings and donation funds at one of Hinduism's most revered shrines in Chamoli, Uttarakhand.
The Missing Evidence
Investigators had initially claimed that 45 days of CCTV recordings from the temple premises had been preserved as evidence. However, according to sources, the investigation team has not yet received footage for 32 of those days. Technical teams are currently working to recover the deleted recordings, though success is not guaranteed.
The shortfall is partly attributed to the inferior quality of previously installed surveillance equipment. Sources indicated that the older cameras had a storage capacity of just 15 days, meaning investigators could only retrieve footage dating back 14 days prior to the key incident on 2 July.
What the Available Footage Shows
Despite the gaps, the footage that was recovered has proven significant. The alleged accused is reportedly visible in recordings from 2 July, appearing to misappropriate money. Investigators also identified several segments from the preceding 14 days as material to the case.
Preliminary findings from the departmental inquiry suggest that the theft of devotees' offerings and valuables did not occur on a single occasion but took place multiple times. A four-member inquiry team documented the full scope of their findings in an 18-page report submitted to the Chief Executive Officer of the temple committee.
Suspension and Departmental Action
The Shri Badrinath-Kedarnath Temple Committee (BKTC) moved swiftly on 7 July, suspending Pramod Nautiyal, a Personal Assistant posted in the Chairman's office, with immediate effect. According to the order issued by the BKTC, prima facie allegations of serious irregularities in the discharge of official duties had surfaced against him.
A show-cause notice had been issued to Nautiyal on 3 July, seeking his explanation. Following examination of his clarifications alongside the committee's preliminary report, the allegations were found to be prima facie correct, prompting the suspension.
Recommendations to Prevent Recurrence
The inquiry report went beyond establishing facts — it also offered concrete recommendations to prevent future incidents. The committee proposed installing additional CCTV cameras in the temple's donation counting room and ensuring that all 'blind spots' along the temple's circumambulation path are covered by surveillance. These gaps in coverage are believed to have facilitated the alleged thefts.
Notably, the BKTC had constituted the four-member panel specifically to ensure an impartial and thorough investigation. With the inquiry report now submitted and departmental action already initiated, the focus shifts to whether the missing footage can be recovered and whether a criminal investigation will follow.