Why Did the Calcutta HC Decline a CBI Probe into the Murshidabad Twin Murders?
Click to start listening
Synopsis
The refusal of the Calcutta High Court to hear a plea for a CBI probe into the twin murders of Hargobindo and Chandan Das raises important questions about judicial processes in communal violence cases. The family seeks justice amid fears of police bias, highlighting the ongoing conflict over investigation credibility.
Key Takeaways
- The Calcutta HC declined a plea for a CBI investigation.
- The twin murders occurred in Murshidabad amidst communal violence.
- The family fears bias from local police.
- Legal experts suggest the case may return to the single-judge bench.
- NCW has recognized the families' concerns regarding police conduct.
Kolkata, May 15 (NationPress) A division bench of the Calcutta High Court on Thursday declined to consider a request for a Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) inquiry into the twin murders of Hargobindo Das and Chandan Das, a father and son tragically killed in communal unrest at Samserganj, located in the minority-heavy district of Murshidabad, West Bengal last month.
On May 5, the relatives of the deceased duo approached the Calcutta High Court’s single-judge bench led by Justice Tirthankar Ghosh, filing a petition for a CBI investigation into the murders.
However, Justice Ghosh opted not to take up the case, indicating that as a matter concerning communal violence was already being reviewed by the division bench of Justice Soumen Sen and Justice Smita Das, the petitioners should redirect their plea to that division bench.
On Thursday, the division bench noted that it is not mandatory for a division bench to handle every case related to violence.
They also stated that the proceedings could be managed by the pertinent single-judge bench, which typically addresses such cases. The family of the deceased expressed a lack of confidence in the state police's investigation into the twin murders, prompting their request for a CBI inquiry.
Additionally, the family has sought protection from the central armed police forces. Legal experts suggest that, given the issues of police misconduct or inaction being examined by Justice Ghosh's single-judge bench, it is likely that the case could eventually return to his court.
Previously, the National Commission for Women (NCW) released a statement indicating that it had urgently acknowledged a request from the widows of the murdered father and son, who accused the West Bengal Police of misconduct against them.
Point of View
It is paramount that we maintain an unbiased perspective while covering sensitive issues such as communal violence and the justice system. The refusal of the Calcutta HC to intervene in this case underscores the complexities involved in ensuring fair investigations, especially when public trust in law enforcement is at stake. Our commitment is to deliver accurate, authoritative reporting that reflects the concerns of the affected families and the broader implications for society.
NationPress
09/06/2025
Frequently Asked Questions
Why was the CBI probe request denied?
The Calcutta HC declined the plea as the matter of communal violence was already under review by a different division bench.
What concerns did the family of the victims express?
The family expressed a lack of faith in the state police's investigation and requested a CBI inquiry for a more impartial examination.
What is the role of the National Commission for Women in this case?
The NCW has taken cognizance of the plea from the widows of the victims, addressing accusations against the West Bengal Police.
