CM Dhami taunts Congress over MLC poll shutout
Synopsis
Key Takeaways
Ballot papers — not EVMs — just delivered a verdict Congress cannot pin on the machines. Uttarakhand Chief Minister Pushkar Singh Dhami on Wednesday, 28 October 2026 congratulated all newly elected members across 28 MLC seats in Uttar Pradesh, Maharashtra, Bihar and Karnataka — and then turned the win into a pointed rebuke of the Congress party.
In his post, Dhami wrote: 'Heartiest congratulations and best wishes to all members elected to the 28 MLC seats in Uttar Pradesh, Maharashtra, Bihar and Karnataka. Congress, which questions EVMs and blames the election process for its defeats, should introspect on the results of these elections conducted via ballot paper as well.'
The dig has a sharp edge. For years, senior Congress figures have questioned the reliability of Electronic Voting Machines after a string of losses — most prominently following the 2019 Lok Sabha elections and several subsequent state polls. The argument, repeated in various forms, was that something was wrong with the machines. MLC elections across these four states use secret ballot, not EVMs, making them an awkward data point for that narrative.
Zero seats, no machine to blame
Dhami did not stop at statistics. He sharpened the question: 'Kांग्रेस के खाते में एक भी सीट नहीं आने के बाद अब सवाल यह है कि इस बार हार की जिम्मेदारी किसे दी जाएगी?' — 'After Congress fails to win even a single seat, the question now is: who will be held responsible for this defeat?'
That rhetorical question points at a recurring internal dynamic within the Congress: accountability after electoral reverses has rarely been clean or swift, and the leadership structure has faced criticism from within the party itself after each major setback since 2014.
BJP's counter-narrative on EVM criticism
This post fits a well-worn BJP playbook — every time indirect elections or ballot-paper polls produce an opposition loss, party leaders hold up the result as proof that Congress loses because voters reject it, not because machines are rigged. The pattern has become almost reflexive after each round of legislative council or assembly by-elections in states that still conduct some polls via traditional ballot.
Dhami closed with a broader indictment: 'Congress must now understand that the people of this country will not trust a party that harbours divisive and anarchic thinking.' The framing casts the MLC results not as a local story about seat arithmetic, but as a national-level verdict on the opposition's credibility.
What the four-state sweep signals
Legislative councils in Uttar Pradesh, Maharashtra, Bihar and Karnataka are elected through an electoral college of local body representatives, MLAs, registered graduates and teachers — a very different voter profile from direct elections, but one that still reflects party strength among organised constituencies. A shutout across all four states simultaneously is a significant organisational signal, not a statistical blip.
Whether Congress responds with a rebuttal or stays silent will say something about how the party intends to manage its electoral messaging ahead of the next cycle of state assembly polls — because the EVM debate, once so central to opposition rhetoric, just lost its most convenient escape hatch.