J&K Dy CM questions BJP over Pakistan Minister's SCO visit to Delhi
Synopsis
Key Takeaways
Jammu and Kashmir Deputy Chief Minister Surinder Choudhary on Friday, 20 November 2026, sharply questioned the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP)-led Centre over permitting Pakistan Minister Musadik Masood Malik to travel to New Delhi to attend the SCO Civilisational Dialogue Forum, drawing attention to what he described as a glaring contradiction in the ruling party's long-held position on engaging with Islamabad.
The Core Contradiction
Choudhary pointed out that the National Conference (NC), including NC President Farooq Abdullah and Chief Minister Omar Abdullah, had for years advocated dialogue with Pakistan — only to be labelled anti-national and pro-separatist by the BJP for doing so. He argued that the Centre's decision to allow the Pakistani minister's visit amounts to an implicit acknowledgment that the NC's position was correct all along.
'Farooq Abdullah also said that there was no alternative to engaging in dialogue with Pakistan. Back then, they accused him of speaking the language of separatists and traitors. If that [Pakistan] Minister is coming today, then why are you allowing him to come?' Choudhary said.
Invoking Vajpayee's Legacy
The Deputy Chief Minister also recalled the stance of the late Prime Minister Atal Bihari Vajpayee, himself a BJP stalwart, who famously argued that nations cannot choose their neighbours and that India must maintain functional relations with Pakistan. Choudhary cited this to reinforce his argument that cross-border engagement has historically enjoyed bipartisan support, even within the BJP's own founding tradition.
'Late Atal Bihari Vajpayee ji had also called for the same thing. He used to say, "You can change friends, but you cannot change your neighbours,"' Choudhary noted.
NC's Sacrifices and Consistent Stance
Choudhary stressed that the National Conference has consistently maintained this position despite enormous personal and political cost, with the party's ministers, MLAs, district presidents, and workers reportedly having lost their lives to violence linked to the Kashmir conflict. He said the party has always maintained that moving forward without engaging Pakistan is 'impossible', given Islamabad's role in the region's instability.
He also referenced Farooq Abdullah's speech in Geneva in 1994, where Abdullah — as part of an Indian opposition delegation led by the then-Opposition Leader Atal Bihari Vajpayee — strongly defended India's human rights record in Jammu and Kashmir and countered a Pakistani-sponsored resolution at an international forum. Choudhary argued that this episode, now widely acknowledged, underlines the NC's firmly pro-India credentials.
The Underlying Message
'The BJP should be asked: when we used to say these things, you called us anti-national. So now that you are doing the same, what does that make you?' Choudhary said, while clarifying that the debate is not fundamentally about patriotism. 'The real issue is that if you want to improve the situation in Jammu and Kashmir, if you want peace and stability in the region, then dialogue with Pakistan is essential,' he added.
The remarks come as India and Pakistan continue to maintain largely frozen diplomatic ties, making the Pakistani minister's presence in Delhi for a multilateral forum a notable, if limited, diplomatic signal. How the Centre responds to the NC's pointed challenge — and whether Malik's visit signals any broader thaw — will be closely watched in the days ahead.