Maharashtra tribal belts lack roads, ambulances: Shiv Sena (UBT) in Saamana

Share:
Audio Loading voice…
Maharashtra tribal belts lack roads, ambulances: Shiv Sena (UBT) in Saamana

Synopsis

A Saamana editorial by Shiv Sena (UBT) has put Maharashtra's tribal governance failure in sharp relief — a pregnant woman carried 7 km on a bamboo stretcher with no road in sight, and grieving parents walking 15 km with their children's bodies because no hearse arrived. The contrast with Chief Minister Fadnavis's 'smart healthcare' messaging could not be starker.

Key Takeaways

Shiv Sena (UBT) attacked the Maharashtra government in a Saamana editorial on 16 September 2026 over absent healthcare and transport infrastructure in tribal belts.
Pregnant woman Phulwanti Devram Padvi from Nandurbar was carried 7 km on a makeshift bamboo-and-cloth stretcher (jholi) with no road access — and 7 km back after delivery.
In Gadchiroli , parents walked 15 kilometres carrying their two deceased children on their shoulders after authorities provided no ambulance or hearse.
The editorial cited recurring issues: rope-bridge river crossings for school children, snakebite deaths on hostel floors, and child malnutrition deaths in Melghat .
The Bombay High Court had previously noted that "child malnutrition among tribals is not an isolated problem, but a failure of government machinery." The editorial criticised Chief Minister Devendra Fadnavis for promoting 'digital and smart healthcare' while ground-level basics remain unmet.

Shiv Sena (Uddhav Balasaheb Thackeray) on Wednesday, 16 September launched a sharp attack on the Maharashtra government, accusing it of leaving tribal communities in districts like Nandurbar and Gadchiroli without basic roads, ambulances, healthcare staff, or essential medicines. The critique was published in an editorial in the party's mouthpiece, Saamana, and cited two recent incidents as evidence of life-threatening administrative failure.

What the Saamana Editorial Said

The editorial accused Maharashtra's rulers of celebrating "rapid development" while fundamental amenities remain absent in remote tribal belts. "Maharashtra's rulers beat their drums about reforms day in and day out, yet this progress has failed to reach the state's remote tribal areas. The struggle and long treks of poor tribals for medical treatment continue unabated," it stated. The Thackeray camp alleged the administration was "dangerously lethargic and unresponsive to judicial warnings."

Two Incidents That Exposed the Gap

The editorial cited a harrowing case from Vehgi-Baripada in Nandurbar district, where a pregnant woman, Phulwanti Devram Padvi, was carried 7 kilometres through the night on a makeshift bamboo-and-cloth stretcher — locally called a jholi — because no roads or river bridges existed. She delivered her child at the Pimpalkhuta health centre and was subsequently carried back the same 7 km on the same stretcher with her newborn.

In a second incident from Gadchiroli district, grieving parents were reportedly forced to walk 15 kilometres carrying the bodies of their two deceased children on their shoulders after local authorities provided neither an ambulance nor a hearse vehicle.

Structural Problems Flagged

Beyond the two incidents, the editorial drew attention to recurring failures across tribal districts: school children crossing rivers on rope bridges, snakebite deaths among girls sleeping on hostel floors for want of beds, and persistent child malnutrition deaths in regions like Melghat. The Thackeray camp invoked a prior observation by the Bombay High Court that "child malnutrition among tribals is not an isolated problem, but a failure of government machinery."

Dig at Fadnavis Over 'Smart Healthcare'

The editorial directed pointed criticism at Chief Minister Devendra Fadnavis over his government's promotion of "smart" and "digital" healthcare services. "Before flying the kite of 'digital and smart healthcare', the state government must first halt the daily struggles, build basic roads, and ensure emergency transportation for tribal communities," the editorial concluded. This comes amid the ruling Mahayuti alliance's ongoing push to brand Maharashtra as a technology-led governance success story — a framing that critics argue rings hollow in districts where the most basic health infrastructure is absent.

Broader Context

Nandurbar and Gadchiroli have historically ranked among Maharashtra's most underserved districts, with tribal populations accounting for a significant share of residents. Successive governments have announced welfare schemes for these regions, yet ground-level delivery has repeatedly drawn censure from courts, civil society organisations, and now opposition parties. The Shiv Sena (UBT) editorial signals that tribal welfare will be a central opposition plank ahead of forthcoming political contests in the state.

Point of View

But the incidents it cites — a woman on a bamboo stretcher, parents carrying children's bodies 15 km — are not contested by the government and point to a systemic failure that transcends party lines. Maharashtra is India's wealthiest state by GDP, which makes the infrastructure deficit in Nandurbar and Gadchiroli not just a governance lapse but a distributive justice question. The Bombay High Court's prior rebuke suggests the judiciary sees this as institutional failure, not bad luck. Whether the Mahayuti government responds with substantive infrastructure spending or symbolic digital announcements will determine whether tribal welfare remains a talking point or becomes a policy priority.
NationPress
16 Sept 2026

Frequently Asked Questions

What did the Saamana editorial accuse the Maharashtra government of?
The Saamana editorial accused the Maharashtra government of neglecting basic roads, ambulances, healthcare staff, and medicines in tribal districts like Nandurbar and Gadchiroli, even as it promoted narratives of rapid development. It cited two recent incidents of tribal families forced to carry patients and deceased relatives on foot due to absent infrastructure.
Who is Phulwanti Devram Padvi and what happened to her?
Phulwanti Devram Padvi is a pregnant woman from Vehgi-Baripada in Nandurbar district who was carried 7 kilometres on a makeshift bamboo-and-cloth stretcher at night because no road or river bridge existed in her area. After delivering her child at the Pimpalkhuta health centre, she and her newborn were carried the same 7 km back on the same stretcher.
What happened in Gadchiroli that the editorial highlighted?
According to the editorial, grieving parents in a remote part of Gadchiroli district were forced to walk 15 kilometres carrying the bodies of their two deceased children on their shoulders because local authorities provided no ambulance or hearse vehicle. The incident was cited as evidence of critical emergency transport failure.
What has the Bombay High Court said about tribal child malnutrition in Maharashtra?
The Bombay High Court previously observed that 'child malnutrition among tribals is not an isolated problem, but a failure of government machinery.' The Shiv Sena (UBT) editorial cited this remark to argue that the state administration has remained unresponsive even to judicial warnings.
Why did Shiv Sena (UBT) criticise Chief Minister Devendra Fadnavis specifically?
The party criticised Chief Minister Devendra Fadnavis for promoting 'smart' and 'digital' healthcare services while tribal communities in Nandurbar and Gadchiroli still lack basic roads and emergency transport. The editorial argued the government must fix ground-level infrastructure before advancing high-tech reform narratives.
Nation Press
The Trail

Connected Dots

Tracing the thread behind this story — newest first.

8 Dots
  1. Latest 3 weeks ago
  2. 2 months ago
  3. 2 months ago
  4. 3 months ago
  5. 4 months ago
  6. 9 months ago
  7. 9 months ago
  8. 1 year ago
Google Prefer NP
On Google