Nadda: Congress wins zero MLC seats in ballot-paper polls
Synopsis
Key Takeaways
The ballot paper — long demanded by Congress as the antidote to alleged EVM manipulation — has delivered its own verdict, and it is ruthless. On Wednesday, 28 October 2026, Union Health Minister and BJP National President J. P. Nadda pointed to results from 28 MLC seats across Uttar Pradesh, Bihar, Karnataka, and Maharashtra, where the grand old party was reduced to precisely zero wins, turning the opposition's favourite talking point against itself.
Ballot papers, zero seats: Congress's own argument backfires
For years, a section of the opposition has argued that Electronic Voting Machines are susceptible to tampering and demanded a return to paper ballots. These 28 MLC (Member of Legislative Council) seats — contested using ballot papers — offered a live test of that theory. The result: BJP and its NDA allies swept the elections while Congress drew a blank across all four states.
Nadda was blunt in his post: 'The problem was never EVMs. The problem is the people's rejection of Congress.' The line lands as both a political jab and a factual observation — whatever the medium, the outcome was the same.
Four states, one story: NDA's sweep from Lucknow to Mumbai
The wins span India's political geography. Uttar Pradesh and Bihar in the Hindi heartland have been consolidating ground for the BJP-NDA combine for over a decade. Maharashtra has swung sharply toward the ruling Mahayuti alliance in recent cycles. Karnataka, where Congress currently holds the Vidhan Sabha, making a MLC shutout there especially stinging for the party.
Legislative Council elections are typically conducted through a preferential voting system among MLAs and local-body representatives — making them a reliable barometer of coalition arithmetic and ground-level party machinery, not just popular sentiment. A zero-seat tally, therefore, reflects a structural collapse of support networks, not merely a bad news cycle.
The EVM debate and what these results mean for it
The demand for ballot papers has been a recurring motif in Indian opposition politics after every major electoral loss since 2014. Critics of EVMs — led at various points by Congress, AAP, and regional parties — have called for Voter Verifiable Paper Audit Trails or an outright return to manual ballots. These MLC elections, which use physical paper ballots, offer the opposition no statistical cover: the technology they asked for produced the same result they have blamed technology for producing.
Nadda's framing — 'every defeat exposes another excuse' — is designed to close that escape route permanently ahead of future electoral cycles.
Twenty-eight seats, four states, zero Congress wins. The ballot paper has spoken, and it has said the same thing the EVM has been saying for years.