Patna High Court bars media trial in Bihar tender scam case
Synopsis
Key Takeaways
The Patna High Court on 26 June issued an interim order restraining media organisations across all platforms from conducting a media trial in connection with the alleged tender scam case involving Bihar contractor Rishu Shree, currently under investigation by the Special Vigilance Unit (SVU). The order, passed by Justice Anshul, underscores that every accused person holds a paramount Constitutional right to a fair trial — a right the court said cannot be compromised by sensationalist coverage.
What the Court Ordered
The interim directions apply to television channels, newspapers, online news portals, podcasts, video-streaming platforms, and social media platforms. The court specifically prohibited media organisations from portraying Rishu Shree as guilty while the case remains sub judice.
Crucially, the court barred the use of terms such as 'mastermind', 'kingpin', and 'scamster', warning that such characterisations could prejudice ongoing proceedings and undermine the accused's right to a fair trial. The court clarified, however, that balanced, factual, and impartial reporting of case developments may continue.
What Is Prohibited
The High Court explicitly prohibited coverage based on alleged confessions, unverified investigative material, documents not yet tested in court, and information that has not been judicially established. The court observed that irresponsible reporting could potentially influence the judicial process and interfere with the administration of justice.
The interim directions will remain in force until further orders. The matter has been listed for the next hearing on 10 July.
Background: The SVU Investigation
The case came to light after the Special Vigilance Unit registered an FIR alleging irregularities involving contractor Rishu Shree. Following the registration, the Bihar government suspended two IAS officers pending investigation.
On 19 June, the SVU conducted searches at multiple premises linked to the suspended officers and a private contractor in Patna. Investigative agencies are currently questioning Rishu Shree in connection with the matter.
Enforcement Directorate Steps In
The Patna Zonal Office of the Enforcement Directorate (ED) separately initiated proceedings under the Prevention of Money Laundering Act (PMLA). The ED conducted searches at locations in Patna, Muzaffarpur, and Gujarat, during which cash amounting to ₹11.64 crore and various documents were reportedly seized, according to the agency.
Investigators are examining financial records, documents, and digital evidence as part of the ongoing probe. All allegations and findings remain under investigation and have yet to be tested before a court of law.
What Happens Next
The next hearing is scheduled for 10 July, when the court is expected to review the interim directions. The case marks one of the more significant judicial interventions on media conduct in Bihar in recent years, and its outcome could set a precedent for how courts balance press freedom against the right to a fair trial in high-profile investigations.