Twisha Sharma case: MP Governor urged to remove mother-in-law from Consumer Forum
Synopsis
Twisha Sharma's father has written to the Madhya Pradesh Governor demanding that his daughter's mother-in-law — a former judge now heading the Bhopal Consumer Court — be removed from her quasi-judicial post while she faces criminal charges in the case. The move puts institutional accountability at the centre of an already sensitive death investigation.
Key Takeaways
Navnidhi Sharma , father of Twisha Sharma , wrote to MP Governor Mangubhai Patel on 20 May seeking removal of Giribala Singh from the State Consumer Forum .
Twisha Sharma allegedly died by suicide at her matrimonial home in Bhopal on 12 May ; police registered an FIR naming Giribala Singh and her son Samarth Singh as co-accused.
Giribala Singh is a former Bhopal District Court judge currently serving as Chairman of the Bhopal Consumer Court .
Medico-legal findings in the FIR reportedly note antemortem hanging and multiple blunt-force injuries .
The family argues that an accused person exercising quasi-judicial authority undermines public confidence in institutional neutrality.
The Governor's office has not yet responded publicly to the representation.
The father of deceased Twisha Sharma on Wednesday, 20 May wrote to Madhya Pradesh Governor Mangubhai Patel, formally requesting the removal of Twisha's mother-in-law Giribala Singh from the State Consumer Forum for the duration of the ongoing criminal investigation into his daughter's death in Bhopal. The letter, submitted by Navnidhi Sharma, argues that an accused individual exercising quasi-judicial authority risks eroding public confidence in institutional fairness.
Background: What Happened to Twisha Sharma
Twisha Sharma allegedly died by suicide at her matrimonial home in Bhopal on 12 May. Following her death, police registered an FIR naming Giribala Singh — a former Bhopal District Court judge currently serving as Chairman of the Bhopal Consumer Court — as a co-accused, along with her son Samarth Singh, who is Twisha's husband. The medico-legal findings recorded in the FIR reportedly noted antemortem hanging and multiple blunt-force injuries, details that Navnidhi Sharma cited as raising serious concerns about the sequence of events preceding his daughter's death.
What the Family Has Sought
In his representation to the Governor, Navnidhi Sharma contended that Giribala Singh's continued exercise of adjudicatory functions during a pending criminal probe could create a reasonable apprehension among litigants, witnesses, and affected parties about the independence of justice-related processes. He stressed that the request was not directed at any institution but was aimed at preserving transparency and investigative independence.
'Where an individual facing serious criminal allegations continues to occupy or exercise adjudicatory authority, a reasonable apprehension may arise in the minds of litigants, witnesses and affected persons regarding fairness and independence of processes connected with administration of justice,' Navnidhi Sharma said in the letter.
The Institutional Concern
The family's submission underscores a broader principle: that those facing serious criminal allegations should, as a matter of constitutional fairness, step aside from quasi-judicial roles until investigations conclude. Navnidhi Sharma noted that Giribala Singh's prior service within the judicial framework makes her current position at the Consumer Forum particularly sensitive. He argued that recusal during the probe would prevent any perception of influence over medico-legal or investigative processes.
'The present representation is being submitted solely in the larger interest of constitutional fairness, investigative independence and preservation of public confidence in administration of justice,' he stated.
What Happens Next
The Governor's office has not issued a public response to the letter as of Wednesday. The criminal investigation into Twisha Sharma's death remains ongoing, with both Giribala Singh and Samarth Singh named as co-accused in the FIR. Whether the Governor acts on the request for Giribala Singh's removal or suspension from the Consumer Forum is expected to be a key development to watch in the coming days.
Point of View
Regardless of the eventual verdict. The Governor's response, or silence, will signal whether Madhya Pradesh treats this as a genuine accountability moment or a procedural inconvenience. Mainstream coverage has focused on the death itself; the institutional integrity question deserves equal scrutiny.
NationPress
13 Aug 2026
Frequently Asked Questions
Who is Giribala Singh in the Twisha Sharma case?
Giribala Singh is Twisha Sharma's mother-in-law and a former Bhopal District Court judge currently serving as Chairman of the Bhopal Consumer Court. She has been named a co-accused in the FIR registered after Twisha Sharma's death on 12 May in Bhopal.
What has Twisha Sharma's father requested from the MP Governor?
Navnidhi Sharma has formally requested Madhya Pradesh Governor Mangubhai Patel to remove or suspend Giribala Singh from the State Consumer Forum for the duration of the criminal investigation, arguing that an accused person in a quasi-judicial role compromises institutional fairness.
How did Twisha Sharma die?
Twisha Sharma allegedly died by suicide at her matrimonial home in Bhopal on 12 May. Medico-legal findings cited in the FIR reportedly recorded antemortem hanging and multiple blunt-force injuries, which her family says raises serious questions about the circumstances of her death.
Who else has been named as co-accused in the Twisha Sharma FIR?
Along with Giribala Singh, her son Samarth Singh — Twisha Sharma's husband — has also been named as a co-accused in the FIR registered by Bhopal police.
Has the Madhya Pradesh Governor responded to the letter?
As of Wednesday, 20 May, the Governor's office had not issued a public response to Navnidhi Sharma's representation. The criminal investigation into Twisha Sharma's death remains ongoing.
