Did Checkmate Organisers Go Too Far in Trolling FIDE CEO for Criticising Nakamura?

Click to start listening
Did Checkmate Organisers Go Too Far in Trolling FIDE CEO for Criticising Nakamura?

Synopsis

In a recent chess match, Hikaru Nakamura's controversial victory over Gukesh Dommaraju sparked widespread debate. As Team USA celebrated a stunning 5-0 win against Team India, Nakamura's actions drew criticism from FIDE officials and admiration from fans. What does this mean for sportsmanship in chess?

Key Takeaways

  • Nakamura's victory over Gukesh led to a 5-0 win for Team USA.
  • His celebration of throwing the king drew mixed reactions.
  • FIDE CEO criticized his actions, raising questions about sportsmanship.
  • Checkmate organisers defended the players' need to entertain the audience.
  • Former champion Kramnik condemned Nakamura's behaviour as childish.

New Delhi, Oct 6 (NationPress) The chess community found itself embroiled in controversy when American GM Hikaru Nakamura, born in Japan, triumphed over the reigning world champion Gukesh Dommaraju, leading Team USA to a dominant 5-0 victory against Team India at the Checkmate: USA vs India. In a moment of exuberance, he seized Gukesh's king and hurled it into a jubilant crowd while celebrating energetically.

This act ignited a flurry of responses on social media, with many deeming his celebration as disrespectful. A clip of Nakamura's actions quickly gained traction online.

FIDE CEO Emil Sutovsky expressed his disapproval of Nakamura's conduct by stating on X, "The event was a spectacle. Fans were thrilled. Players were encouraged to act accordingly. All true. Now, for better or worse, name me one top player who would do what Hikaru did."

In response, the Checkmate organisers took a jibe at Sutovsky, saying, "On behalf of the organisers, we confess to having compelled the players to entertain, to delight the audience, and to disregard FIDE Etiquette. We genuinely apologize if the players, the live audience, and the overwhelming majority of online viewers enjoyed themselves."

Nakamura reacted to the organisers' comment by posting a series of laughing emojis.

Looking back at the match, Nakamura and Gukesh began with a solid draw that featured a bishop endgame. In the subsequent five-minute game, Nakamura engaged the crowd with his opening move 1.b4. While initially securing a favorable position on the queenside, he found himself gradually outplayed, and Gukesh appeared to be in a winning position for a considerable duration.

The game was ultimately decided under intense time pressure for both competitors. With limited time to think clearly, the world champion made a significant blunder related to his vulnerable dark squares.

Gukesh eventually allowed a checkmate in one when he could have opted for a repetition of moves to secure another draw, which would have led to a bullet game. Instead, Team USA celebrated a remarkable 5-0 victory over Team India. After clinching the win, Nakamura again made headlines by tossing Gukesh's king into the crowd.

Former world champion and Russian Grandmaster Vladimir Kramnik launched a sharp critique of world no. 2 Nakamura, labeling his actions as a "childish, tasteless act."

"I don’t know who devised this childish, tasteless act. Likely this 'thinker' had no intention to humiliate Gukesh, but he should have realized that this public gesture (using opponent’s KING) appears offensive and provocative, especially against the World Champion," he stated on X.

Point of View

It is crucial to acknowledge both sides of this unfolding narrative. While Nakamura's actions may have entertained many, they also raise significant questions about respect and sportsmanship within the chess community. As we navigate this complex issue, we must prioritize the integrity of the game while recognizing the evolving dynamics of competitive sports.
NationPress
06/10/2025

Frequently Asked Questions

What sparked the controversy involving Nakamura and Gukesh?
The controversy began when Nakamura defeated Gukesh and celebrated by throwing the Indian GM's king into the crowd, which many deemed disrespectful.
How did FIDE CEO Emil Sutovsky respond to Nakamura's actions?
Sutovsky criticized Nakamura's behaviour on social media, questioning the appropriateness of such actions by top players.
What was the Checkmate organisers' reaction to the criticism?
The organisers sarcastically admitted to encouraging players to entertain the crowd, apologizing for any enjoyment derived from the event.
What was Vladimir Kramnik's opinion on Nakamura's act?
Kramnik described Nakamura's behaviour as 'childish' and 'tasteless', highlighting the offensive nature of using an opponent's king in celebration.
What was the final score of the match between Team USA and Team India?
Team USA achieved an impressive 5-0 victory over Team India.
Nation Press