Should ICC Rules Permit Like-for-Like Substitutes?
Click to start listening
Synopsis
In light of Rishabh Pant's unfortunate injury in the fourth Test against England, former England captain Michael Vaughan advocates for a change in ICC rules. He argues that allowing a like-for-like substitute for first innings injuries would enhance the integrity of the game. Could this change be the key to fair play in cricket?
Key Takeaways
- Michael Vaughan calls for like-for-like substitutes for injuries in Test matches.
- The current ICC rules do not permit substitutes for injured players.
- Rishabh Pant sustained a toe injury that may keep him out for the rest of the match.
- Substitutions could enhance the game's integrity by ensuring teams compete on equal footing.
- Vaughan’s argument highlights the need for rule adaptations in cricket.
Manchester, July 24 (NationPress) Former England captain Michael Vaughan has voiced his opinion that the rules should permit a like-for-like substitute for injuries incurred during the first innings of a Test match. This comes after a toe fracture nearly sidelined Rishabh Pant for the rest of the fourth Test against England.
Pant, who had to retire hurt on 37 after sustaining a blow to his right toe from Chris Woakes in the final session, has been advised to rest for six weeks to recover from the injury, according to reports.
The Indian vice-captain was seen in considerable distress as the physiotherapist rushed onto the field to assist him. He remained on the ground for several minutes, unable to bear weight on his injured foot, and ultimately needed assistance to leave the field.
Vaughan expressed his views on X, stating, "For clear and evident injuries during the first innings of Tests, we should implement like-for-like substitutions. We already have concussion substitutes, so it stands to reason we can have substitutes for injuries like Rishabh's..."
“I dislike the notion that with four days still remaining in the match, we may end up with 10 players competing against 11 in what has been a thrilling series,” he elaborated on BBC Sports.
“I believe substitutions should be allowed. When concussion substitutes were introduced, I advocated for having substitutions available in the first innings. If such an injury occurs in the second innings, I worry that teams might exploit the rules. However, when it’s obvious that someone is seriously injured, like a fractured hand or foot, it’s clear they can’t continue. Therefore, I firmly believe a substitute should be allowed.”
With current ICC regulations prohibiting a substitute for an injured player during a match, the Indian team will be left with just ten players for the remainder of the game if Pant is unable to return to bat in the second innings.
Point of View
I recognize the importance of adapting cricket's rules to uphold fair play. The debate surrounding like-for-like substitutes for injuries is not just a matter of safety, but also of maintaining the competitive spirit of the game. It is essential for the ICC to consider these changes to protect players and ensure that every match is contested on equal terms.
NationPress
26/07/2025
Frequently Asked Questions
What are ICC rules regarding substitutes for injuries?
Currently, ICC rules do not allow for substitutes for injuries sustained during the match, except for designated concussion substitutes.
Why is Michael Vaughan advocating for a rule change?
Vaughan believes that allowing like-for-like substitutes for injuries in the first innings would maintain the competitive integrity of the match.
How does a like-for-like substitute work?
A like-for-like substitute would allow a player who is injured to be replaced by another player of similar skill level, ensuring the team can continue to compete effectively.
What injury did Rishabh Pant sustain?
Rishabh Pant suffered a toe fracture after being struck by a ball bowled by Chris Woakes during the match.
What are the implications for the Indian team if Pant cannot return?
If Pant cannot return to bat in the second innings, India will have to play with only ten players for the remainder of the match.
