How can a Pak-friendly US be beneficial for us?
Click to start listening
Synopsis
In a thought-provoking interview, senior Congress leader Mani Shankar Aiyar challenges the United States' dual engagement with India and Pakistan. He questions the benefits of such a relationship for India and highlights the implications of America's strategic ties with Islamabad amidst its claims of being a close ally to New Delhi.
Key Takeaways
- US-Pakistan relations create skepticism in India.
- Major events like 'Howdy Modi' do not alleviate concerns.
- India's economic policies face challenges from US tariffs.
- The Indian government is criticized for its response to US claims.
- Maintaining balanced foreign relations is crucial for India's growth.
New Delhi, Aug 2 (NationPress) Senior Congress figure Mani Shankar Aiyar expressed skepticism regarding the United States' dual engagement with both India and Pakistan, questioning how Washington's relationship with Islamabad serves New Delhi's interests while simultaneously asserting its close alliance with India.
Aiyar pointed out that despite the government's attempts to highlight robust Indo-US relations through events such as 'Howdy Modi' and 'Namaste Trump', the US continues to sustain its strategic ties with Pakistan.
In an interview with IANS, Aiyar stated, "We must demonstrate to the world that we are independent and not pursuing friendships. It is crucial for both nations to foster amicable relations. Maintaining contrasting relationships with China and the US is not a sound foreign policy."
"Even the younger generation perceives that despite grand events like 'Howdy Modi' and 'Namaste Trump', the prevailing situation is such that Pakistan is receiving accolades. They are welcoming a Pakistani Field Marshal, known for self-promotion. On one hand, the US claims to be an excellent friend of India, yet on the other, it is engaging with Pakistan. How does this serve our interests?"
On the economic front, Aiyar criticized the 25 percent tariffs imposed on India by the US, stating, "America asserts that India has the highest tariffs globally. Trump is taking credit for the ceasefire agreement. While Pakistan acknowledges it, India refutes any claims of mediation. Thus, Islamabad reaps the rewards, while we endure the consequences."
He also accused the government of lacking the fortitude to challenge the US administration regarding unsubstantiated claims.
Aiyar remarked, "Trump has repeatedly asserted that the US facilitated the ceasefire agreement between India and Pakistan, yet our government hesitates to declare him untruthful. The administration lacks the courage to confront their so-called allies and adversaries honestly," Aiyar concluded.
Point of View
We must emphasize the importance of a balanced foreign policy that prioritizes India's interests while navigating complex international relationships. Aiyar's insights reflect a growing concern among political leaders regarding US-Pakistan dynamics and their implications for India. It is essential to remain vigilant and advocate for a foreign policy that supports India's sovereignty and strategic goals.
NationPress
19/08/2025
Frequently Asked Questions
What is Mani Shankar Aiyar's stance on US-India relations?
Aiyar expresses doubts about the effectiveness of US-India relations, particularly in light of America's continued engagement with Pakistan.
How does Aiyar believe US policies affect India?
He argues that the US's strategic proximity to Pakistan undermines India's interests, suggesting that these dual relationships are detrimental.
What economic concerns did Aiyar raise?
Aiyar criticized the 25% tariffs imposed by the US on India, claiming that India faces unfair economic repercussions while Pakistan benefits.
