Karnataka Cabinet expansion: BJP alleges 'payment quota', tainted ministers
Synopsis
Key Takeaways
R. Ashoka, senior Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) leader and Leader of the Opposition in Karnataka, on Tuesday, 4 August alleged that the newly expanded Karnataka Cabinet had accommodated 'tainted' leaders and that several ministerial berths were secured through a so-called 'payment quota.' Addressing a press conference in Bengaluru, Ashoka claimed the reshuffle lacked fresh faces and reflected a lack of autonomy on the part of Chief Minister D.K. Shivakumar in selecting his own team.
Core Allegations Against the Expanded Cabinet
'The new Cabinet is filled with tainted leaders, and many have found a place through a payment quota. It is evident that the Chief Minister did not have the freedom to choose his own team,' Ashoka alleged. He specifically questioned the re-induction of B. Nagendra, who was previously removed from the ministry in connection with the alleged Maharshi Valmiki Scheduled Tribes Development Corporation scam — a case involving the alleged diversion of funds meant for Scheduled Tribe welfare for election purposes.
Ashoka claimed that former Chief Minister Siddaramaiah had himself acknowledged in the Assembly that funds had been misappropriated. 'Nagendra went to jail in connection with the case. Who gave him a clean chit and brought him back into the Cabinet?' he asked. He alleged the present leadership had 'washed him clean' and reinstated him without accountability.
Regional and Community Representation Gaps
Ashoka further criticised the Cabinet for allegedly failing to provide balanced regional representation. He said districts including Yadgir, Raichur, Vijayanagar, Kolar, and Chikkaballapur had been left without a minister, while several communities had also been overlooked. He also criticised the Indian National Congress (Congress) for not inducting a single woman into the expanded Cabinet.
'Women constitute nearly 50 per cent of the population, yet not a single woman has been made a minister. This is a betrayal of the women of Karnataka,' he alleged. He pointed to Congress MLC Gayathri Shanthegowda, whose name reportedly appeared in an initial list but who was ultimately excluded from the final Cabinet.
Internal Congress Discontent and Constitutional Concerns
The BJP leader pointed to protests by Congress legislators and workers following the expansion as evidence of widespread dissatisfaction within the ruling party. 'Some legislators have threatened to resign, and Congress workers themselves are protesting against the government,' Ashoka alleged, adding that Congress workers had reportedly attacked the Chief Minister's posters and raised slogans against him.
He also alleged that the last-minute inclusion of S.S. Mallikarjun in place of Mankal Vaidya suggested financial influence over the final list. Additionally, Ashoka accused the Congress of violating constitutional conventions by announcing names for the posts of Speaker, Deputy Speaker, Legislative Council Chairman, and Deputy Chairman on the party's letterhead — treating constitutional offices, he alleged, as ordinary appointments.
Cauvery Dispute and Legislature Strategy
Commenting on the Cauvery water dispute, Ashoka said Tamil Nadu had approached the Supreme Court seeking implementation of water release directions, and cautioned the Karnataka government against decisions that could compromise the state's interests. He alleged that if the Karnataka government released water to Tamil Nadu after reaching an understanding with Tamil Nadu Chief Minister Joseph Vijay, people of the state 'would not remain silent.'
Ashoka announced that the BJP would hold an internal meeting on Friday ahead of the Legislature session to finalise its strategy for raising issues relating to the Cabinet expansion, drought, and the Cauvery dispute in both Houses. The opposition's coordinated push signals that the new Cabinet's composition will face sustained political scrutiny in the coming days.