Guyana's Rodrigues-Birkett leads UN Secretary-General straw poll
Synopsis
Key Takeaways
Former Guyana Foreign Minister Carolyn Rodrigues-Birkett has emerged as the frontrunner for the post of UN Secretary-General after topping the second informal straw poll conducted by the UN Security Council on Friday, 22 August, according to unofficial tabulations published by advocacy group 1 for 8 Billion and UN-focused media outlet Pass Blue.
Rodrigues-Birkett, who had ranked second in the first informal poll held last month, edged past UNCTAD head Rebecca Grynspan, who had led that earlier round. The shift marks a significant reshuffling of the field with no clear consensus candidate yet in sight.
Key Poll Results
Rodrigues-Birkett secured eight positive or 'encourage' votes, three negative or 'discourage' votes, and four neutral votes in the 15-member Council, according to the leaked tabulations. Despite leading the field, she fell one short of the nine positive votes required for election — and critically, none of those nine must come from a veto-wielding permanent member voting against her.
Compared to last month's poll, she dropped one positive vote while picking up one additional negative, suggesting her support base is not yet consolidated.
Grynspan's Slide and the Shifting Field
The most dramatic movement was in Grynspan's tally. The former Vice-President of Costa Rica saw her 'encourage' votes fall sharply from ten in July to seven in this round, while 'discourage' votes climbed from one to four. The reversal signals that the race remains fluid and no candidate has yet locked in the support needed to proceed to the 193-member General Assembly, which by convention endorses the Council's recommendation.
International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) Director General Rafael Grossi of Argentina held third place with seven positive and six negative votes. Newcomer Ivonne A-Baki, a former Ecuadorian Ambassador to the United States and France who entered the race after last month's poll, received no positive votes and accumulated eight negative votes.
Other Candidates in the Race
The remaining candidates — former Chilean President and UN Human Rights High Commissioner Michelle Bachelet; former General Assembly President and Ecuador's ex-Foreign Minister Maria Fernanda Espinosa; former UN Under-Secretary-General and Uganda's ex-Foreign Minister Olara Otunnu; and former Senegal President Macky Sall — all trailed the frontrunners.
Russia Leaves Door Open for New Entrants
Adding to the uncertainty, Russia's Permanent Representative Vasily Nebenzia, whose country holds veto power on the Council, suggested on Thursday that a deadlock could open the field to new candidates. 'I am speculating now,' Nebenzia said, 'if there is a deadlock on any of the candidates we are seeing today, if nobody flies, then I think that we may see other candidates.'
Officially, the straw poll results are confidential. Denmark's Permanent Representative Christina Lassen, serving as this month's Council president, declined to release the figures — though they leaked regardless. The early-stage polls do not yet colour-code permanent members' votes, meaning it remains unclear where the five veto powers stand on each candidate.
With no candidate yet commanding the required threshold and a permanent member openly flagging the possibility of fresh entrants, the race to lead the United Nations remains wide open heading into the next round of consultations.