Calcutta HC extends Abhishek Banerjee's arrest protection till Jan 27, rebukes him over judiciary remarks
Synopsis
Key Takeaways
The Calcutta High Court on Friday, 20 November 2026, extended interim protection from coercive police action — including arrest — for All India Trinamool Congress (TMC) General Secretary and Diamond Harbour Member of Parliament Abhishek Banerjee until 27 January 2027, in a case involving alleged threats made against Union Home Minister Amit Shah at an election campaign rally ahead of the West Bengal Assembly elections.
While granting the relief, a single-judge bench of Justice Saugata Bhattacharyya openly expressed displeasure over Banerjee's alleged derogatory remarks targeting a section of the judiciary in recent days, calling them 'very unfortunate.'
Court's Sharp Rebuke Over Judiciary Remarks
Justice Bhattacharyya questioned the signal such comments by a sitting Member of Parliament would send to his supporters. 'Such comments against the judiciary are very unfortunate,' the judge observed from the bench. The court further stated that while the remarks were unacceptable and 'painful for the court,' they might not have been intentional and may therefore not necessarily amount to contempt of court.
'Such comments could have been avoided. Such comments against the court are not acceptable. It is painful for the court,' Justice Bhattacharyya said, stopping short of initiating contempt proceedings.
State Government's Opposition Rejected
The West Bengal state government opposed the extension of Banerjee's interim protection, citing precisely those alleged anti-judiciary remarks as grounds for denial. Justice Bhattacharyya rejected the argument, holding that the question of protection from arrest and any potential contempt proceedings are legally distinct matters.
'The two issues are different. If the right circumstances arise, a contempt of court case can be initiated. But that is a completely different legal process,' the judge clarified. The ruling means that contempt proceedings remain a live possibility even as the arrest protection stands extended.
Background: The Case Against Banerjee
The case stems from a complaint registered at the Bidhannagar Cyber Police Station on 15 May, shortly after the West Bengal Assembly election results were declared. The complaint accused Banerjee of making provocative remarks and allegedly threatening Shah at a pre-poll campaign rally.
Banerjee's earlier interim protection had lapsed on 6 November. On 16 November, he approached the High Court through his counsel seeking a fresh extension. Friday's order restores and extends that cover until 27 January 2027. During earlier proceedings, Justice Bhattacharyya had also directed Banerjee to provide a voice sample to the investigating agency.
Broader Legal Context
This is not an isolated legal battle. Banerjee has faced multiple police complaints and First Information Reports (FIRs) at various police stations across West Bengal since the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) came to power in the state. The pattern reflects a wider political and legal contest between the ruling TMC leadership and the BJP-led Centre, playing out in courtrooms alongside electoral arenas.
Notably, the court's willingness to rebuke Banerjee even while extending his relief signals that judicial institutions are drawing a clear line between procedural protection and institutional respect — a distinction that will likely shape how future proceedings in this case unfold.
The next hearing is set for 27 January 2027, when the court will revisit both the protection order and, if circumstances warrant, any question of contempt.