Why Did Congress Criticize PM Modi's Praise for RSS in I-Day Speech?
Click to start listening
Synopsis
In a striking rebuke, Congress MP Jairam Ramesh has condemned PM Modi's praise for the RSS during his Independence Day address. This incident raises questions about the intertwining of politics and national celebrations in India. Explore the implications of such statements on India's secular fabric and the political discourse surrounding Independence Day.
Key Takeaways
- PM Modi's praise for the RSS during Independence Day raises concerns about the secular nature of the republic.
- Congress MP Jairam Ramesh criticized the speech for being self-serving and lacking substance.
- The speech failed to address pressing economic issues faced by the nation.
- Ramesh demanded clarity on electoral processes to ensure fair representation.
- The politicization of national events can undermine democratic values.
New Delhi, Aug 15 (NationPress) Congress MP and former Union Minister Jairam Ramesh on Friday criticized Prime Minister Narendra Modi for lauding the Rashtriya Swayamsewak Sangh — the ideological backbone of the ruling BJP — during his Independence Day address.
Immediately after PM Modi acknowledged the social contributions of the RSS, described as the “world’s largest NGO”, Ramesh remarked, “The Prime Minister's speech from the ramparts of the Red Fort today was stale, hypocritical, lacklustre, and alarming.”
He characterized the PM’s 103-minute speech as a “dull mix of self-praise” and stated on X, “The most alarming aspect of the Prime Minister’s speech today was mentioning the RSS from the ramparts of the Red Fort — a blatant violation of the spirit of a constitutional, secular republic.”
Ramesh emphasized that politicizing a national event like Independence Day for personal and organizational benefits undermines our democratic values, as noted by the General Secretary in charge of Communications for the Congress party.
This I-Day speech wasn’t the first time PM Modi extolled the RSS. Earlier this year, in a podcast with AI researcher Lex Fridman, he credited the RSS with providing him a sense of purpose and instilling a service-oriented philosophy.
“Through the RSS, I found a life of purpose. Then I was fortunate to spend some time among the saints, which gave me a strong spiritual foundation. I found discipline and a life of purpose,” he expressed.
The PM also highlighted the various social causes the RSS has supported over the past century, benefiting tribals, women, laborers, and youth.
Previously, Ramesh contended that PM Modi’s I-Day address failed to address the country’s pressing economic issues, including economic distress, unemployment, and rising inequality.
He claimed that PM Modi’s assurances to protect farmers now appear insincere, especially after the attempt to enforce three controversial agricultural laws.
“Even today, there is no concrete announcement regarding a legal guarantee for MSP, fixing MSP with a 50% profit over costs, or loan waivers,” he said, also criticizing the lack of a credible roadmap for job creation.
The Congress MP demanded transparency in the electoral process, stating, “In Bihar, millions of voters are being deprived through the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of voter lists.”
Point of View
The criticism by Congress MP Jairam Ramesh reflects ongoing tensions in India's political landscape. It is crucial to uphold the principles of a secular republic, especially during national celebrations. This incident underscores the importance of maintaining a clear distinction between political ideology and national identity, ensuring that democratic values remain at the forefront of public discourse.
NationPress
20/08/2025
Frequently Asked Questions
What did Jairam Ramesh say about PM Modi's speech?
Jairam Ramesh criticized PM Modi's speech, describing it as stale and alarmingly hypocritical, especially for praising the RSS during a national event.
Why is the RSS significant in Indian politics?
The RSS is considered the ideological foundation of the ruling BJP, influencing its policies and political strategies.
What are the concerns raised about Modi's focus on the RSS?
Critics argue that praising the RSS during Independence Day compromises the secular ethos of the nation, which is vital to India's democratic framework.
How did Modi's speech address economic issues?
Ramesh pointed out that Modi's speech lacked any substantive discussion on pressing economic challenges facing the country, such as unemployment and inequality.
What demands did Ramesh make regarding electoral processes?
Ramesh called for transparency and accountability in the electoral process, highlighting concerns about voter disenfranchisement in Bihar.
