Why Did CM Abdullah and the Education Minister Oppose the Public Holiday in J&K on Friday?
Click to start listening
Synopsis
The decision to observe a public holiday for Eid-e-Milad on a Friday, instead of the customary Saturday, has ignited controversy in Jammu and Kashmir. Key leaders, including CM Omar Abdullah and Education Minister Sakina Itoo, have expressed their discontent, emphasizing the importance of adhering to the lunar sighting for this significant occasion. What does this mean for the community's sentiments?
Key Takeaways
- Public holiday controversy over Eid-e-Milad in J&K.
- Omar Abdullah challenges the holiday's timing.
- Significance of lunar sightings in Islamic traditions.
- Calls for respecting religious sentiments.
- Community leaders urge for decision-making by elected officials.
Srinagar, Sep 5 (NationPress) A debate has sparked in J&K regarding the announcement of a public holiday on Friday for the Eid-e-Milad-ul-Nabi (the Prophet's Birthday).
This official holiday was observed in J&K on Friday, aligned with all Central government offices across the nation.
Chief Minister Omar Abdullah challenged the decision to mark Eid-e-Milad on Friday rather than Saturday.
"The calendar produced by the Government press is explicit - Subject to the sighting of the moon. This indicates that the holiday is contingent on the moon being spotted. The intentional choice by the unelected administration not to alter the holiday is inconsiderate and appears designed to offend the sentiments of the populace," he stated in a post on his X account.
Education Minister Sakina Itoo also voiced her disapproval of the decision. "It is utterly unjust that Eid-e-Milad, a significant occasion for Muslims globally, is not recognized as a holiday on the proper date in J&K. What does 'subject to appearance of the moon' imply if not adhered to? Despite repeated pleas from the elected government to move the holiday, no steps have been taken," she remarked on X.
"This is manipulating the feelings of the public. Such decisions should rest with the elected government," Itoo added.
The Grand Mufti of Kashmir, Nasir-ul-Islam, also articulated his profound disappointment, labeling the government's failure to synchronize the official holiday for Eid-e-Milad with the moon sighting as troubling.
In a statement, he remarked: "It is extremely unfortunate that although Eid Milad falls on Saturday according to the moon sighting, the Government did not adjust the notice accordingly. This complete inconsistency showcases a negative attitude towards a day that is both spiritually and religiously significant."
He called on the authorities to ensure that such inconsistencies do not occur in the future, emphasizing the need to respect and uphold the sanctity of religious events.
Typically, the nightlong prayers for Eid-e-Milad are followed by a public holiday in J&K, and according to the Islamic calendar, these prayers will take place on Friday night.
Point of View
It is vital to recognize that the sentiments surrounding religious observances are deeply rooted in cultural significance. The controversy in J&K illustrates the complexities of governance in a diverse society. The call for elected representatives to make decisions reflects the need for responsiveness to the community's beliefs and practices, ensuring that the integrity of religious occasions is upheld.
NationPress
05/09/2025
Frequently Asked Questions
Why was the public holiday for Eid-e-Milad declared on a Friday?
The holiday was declared in line with the central government offices, but local leaders argue it should align with lunar sightings.
What are the objections raised by Omar Abdullah?
Omar Abdullah criticized the government for not being considerate of lunar sightings, calling the decision inconsiderate.
How did Sakina Itoo respond to the holiday announcement?
Sakina Itoo expressed that it was unjust not to observe the holiday on the correct date, urging action from the authorities.
What is the Grand Mufti's stance on the holiday decision?
The Grand Mufti expressed disappointment over the government's failure to align the holiday with the lunar sighting.
How are religious sentiments being respected in this decision?
The criticism suggests that the decision overlooks the significance of lunar sightings, which are crucial for religious observance.
