CPI(M) MP Su Venkatesan fires back at Madras HC judge over lifestyle remarks
Synopsis
Key Takeaways
Communist Party of India (Marxist) Lok Sabha member Su Venkatesan on Tuesday, 17 November strongly pushed back against Madras High Court Justice G.R. Swaminathan's remarks questioning his lifestyle and ideological commitment, asserting that political convictions and actions carry far greater weight than outward appearance or mode of travel. The Madurai MP categorically denied owning a luxury vehicle, clarifying that the Mercedes-Benz he was seen arriving in at a railway station did not belong to him and that he had never owned a car.
How the Controversy Erupted
The row began on Monday, 16 November, when Justice Swaminathan made observations from the bench of the Madurai Bench of the Madras High Court during the hearing of a contempt petition related to alleged irregularities in the procurement of books for public libraries. The judge recalled a personal encounter with Venkatesan at a railway station while travelling on the Pandian Express from Chennai to Madurai. He questioned how a professed Communist could lead what he described as a 'corporate' lifestyle, noting that Venkatesan had arrived in a Mercedes-Benz, sported branded clothes, and was travelling in First AC — while the judge himself was in Sleeper Class.
Venkatesan's Point-by-Point Rebuttal
Responding through a detailed post on social media platform X, Venkatesan maintained that the ideological positions and political outlook of those scrutinising another person's lifestyle were more significant than superficial appearances. He argued that criticism based on unverified observations reflected prejudice and amounted to a personal attack. On the First AC travel, the parliamentarian clarified that his ticket was covered under the official travel entitlements available to Members of Parliament — a standard perquisite. He further argued that travelling in first class could no more invalidate a person's political views than travelling in Sleeper Class could automatically lend credibility to someone's judgements.
Ideology and Accountability
The CPI(M) leader reaffirmed that Communists were accountable to the people and had a responsibility to address questions raised about their commitment to simplicity and personal integrity. He stated that his political upbringing had instilled in him the duty to question and challenge matters of public concern, and that personal criticism would not deter him from pursuing those principles. Notably, the exchange has drawn attention to broader questions about whether a public figure's lifestyle choices can be legitimately scrutinised from the bench, and where the boundary lies between judicial observation and personal commentary.
Wider Significance
This is not the first time Justice Swaminathan has made headline-generating remarks from the bench — the judge has previously drawn attention for pointed observations on social and political matters during hearings. The incident has reignited debate within Tamil Nadu's political circles about the intersection of judicial conduct, political ideology, and personal accountability. The underlying contempt petition concerning library book procurement remains under adjudication at the Madurai Bench. How the court proceeds — and whether Tuesday's public exchange influences the atmosphere of the proceedings — will be closely watched.