Calcutta HC division bench to hear challenge to Aroop Biswas's interim protection in Messi event case
Synopsis
Key Takeaways
A division bench of the Calcutta High Court, comprising Chief Justice Sujoy Paul and Justice Partha Sarathi Sen, on Tuesday, 16 June admitted a petition challenging an earlier single-judge order that had granted interim protection from coercive police action to former West Bengal minister Aroop Biswas until 17 August. The matter stems from alleged mismanagement during Lionel Messi's 'GOAT India Tour' exhibition event at Yuva Bharati Krirangan in Salt Lake, Kolkata, on 13 December last year.
Background: The Messi Event and Its Fallout
The high-profile football event, held at the iconic Salt Lake Stadium, was marred by severe crowd management failures that reportedly led to chaos inside the venue and prompted Lionel Messi to exit early due to security concerns. Of the 70,000 tickets issued for the event, Biswas — then serving as the state's sports and power minister in the Mamata Banerjee-led cabinet — allegedly reserved 22,000 tickets for residents of his Tollygunge Assembly constituency in southern Kolkata, according to submissions made before the court.
Biswas's counsel further alleged that these tickets were subsequently sold at premium rates to several clubs, compounding concerns about financial irregularities tied to the event.
The Single-Judge Order and Police Investigation
Following the state government's initiation of a formal investigation into the mismanagement, Biswas approached a single-judge vacation bench of the Calcutta High Court presided over by Justice Saugata Bhattacharya, seeking protection from arrest and other coercive police measures. On 10 June, Justice Bhattacharya granted Biswas interim protection until 17 August, while simultaneously directing that the police investigation would continue unimpeded under law. The bench also stipulated that Biswas must appear before the investigating agency if served with a notice.
An FIR against Biswas was registered by police based on a complaint filed by event organiser Satadru Dutta, who was himself arrested during the previous Trinamool Congress (TMC) regime in connection with the mismanagement.
Division Bench Challenge
On Tuesday, Dutta moved the division bench of the Calcutta High Court challenging the single-judge vacation bench's protective order in favour of Biswas. The petition has been accepted, and the matter is scheduled to come up for hearing this week. The challenge raises questions about whether the interim protection afforded to Biswas is legally sustainable given the gravity of the allegations and the ongoing criminal investigation.
Biswas Family Under Scrutiny
The legal pressure on the Biswas family extends beyond Aroop. His brother, Swarup Biswas, was recently arrested by police on multiple charges including corruption, extortion, and alleged inappropriate behaviour towards women support staff in the Bengali film industry. The twin cases have intensified scrutiny of the former minister's political network in the post-TMC-government transition period.
The division bench's upcoming hearing could determine whether Biswas retains his legal shield or faces the prospect of police action as the investigation deepens.