Did the Jharkhand HC Uphold the JPSC Civil Services Exam Results?
Click to start listening
Synopsis
In a significant ruling, the Jharkhand High Court has upheld the results of the Combined Civil Services Main Examination. This decision comes after a petition raised concerns about the examination process, but the court found no merit in those objections.
Key Takeaways
- The Jharkhand High Court has upheld the results of the JPSC Civil Services Examination.
- The court found no merit in the petition challenging the examination process.
- Timeliness in raising concerns is critical in legal proceedings.
- The evaluation process was deemed consistent and fair by the court.
- A total of 342 posts are set to be filled through this recruitment.
Ranchi, July 3 (NationPress) The Jharkhand High Court has dismissed a petition contesting the outcome of the 11th to 13th Combined Civil Services Main Examination organized by the Jharkhand Public Service Commission (JPSC).
The ruling was delivered by Justice Deepak Roshan, following a review of arguments from both sides. The petitioners, Ayub Tirkey and Rajesh Kumar, raised multiple concerns regarding the advertisement and merit list published in 2024 for the civil services examination.
In their petition, they asserted that the digital assessment of answer sheets was conducted in contravention of established rules, which disallow such a procedure. They claimed a third-party agency was utilized for evaluation, but details regarding the agency’s identity and the tendering process for its appointment were not disclosed.
The petitioners also contended that the assessment of regional language papers was performed by examiners lacking the requisite 10 years of experience.
In light of these concerns, the petitioners called for the annulment of the examination results.
During the previous hearing, the court had served a notice to the JPSC, requesting a response to the allegations.
On Thursday, advocate Sanjay Piperwal, representing the JPSC, argued that the petitioners only voiced their objections after failing the examination.
"If they had issues with the examination process, they should have raised them sooner -- not after the results were published. The same regulations were consistently applied to all candidates, and there was no discrimination," he stated.
Following the arguments, the court remarked that the petitioners' objections were not presented within a reasonable timeframe and found insufficient grounds to invalidate the results.
The court noted that no irregularities were detected in the evaluation process that could justify such an action.
The advertisement for the JPSC’s 11th to 13th Combined Civil Services Examination was released in January 2024, with the preliminary exam taking place in March 2024, attracting over 3.5 lakh candidates. The preliminary results were published on April 22, subsequently shortlisting 7,011 candidates for the main examination.
The main examination was conducted from June 22 to 24, 2024, and the results were revealed on May 20, 2025.
The process of announcing successful candidates has been finalized, with a total of 342 posts set to be filled through this recruitment endeavor.
Point of View
The Jharkhand High Court's ruling reinforces the integrity of the examination process conducted by the JPSC. It emphasizes the importance of adhering to established protocols and raises questions about the responsibility of candidates to voice concerns in a timely manner.
NationPress
03/07/2025
Frequently Asked Questions
What was the petition about?
The petition challenged the results of the JPSC Civil Services Main Examination, alleging irregularities in the evaluation process.
What was the court's decision?
The Jharkhand High Court dismissed the petition, stating that the objections raised were not timely and lacked sufficient grounds.
Who were the petitioners?
The petition was filed by Ayub Tirkey and Rajesh Kumar.
What are the implications of this ruling?
The ruling upholds the validity of the examination results and emphasizes the importance of following proper procedures.
How many candidates participated in the examination?
Over 3.5 lakh candidates appeared for the preliminary examination.
