Did Karnataka HC Uphold the Mandate for Smart Electricity Meters?
Click to start listening
Synopsis
The Karnataka High Court has upheld the state government's mandate for new electricity consumers to install smart pre-paid meters. This controversial decision has raised concerns about the high cost of these meters compared to neighboring states, igniting political tensions and calls for transparency.
Key Takeaways
- Karnataka High Court dismisses petitions against smart pre-paid meters.
- The cost of smart meters is significantly higher in Karnataka.
- Only new electricity consumers are affected by the mandate.
- The ruling has political ramifications for the Congress-led government.
- Concerns about affordability and potential corruption have been raised.
Bengaluru, Aug 13 (NationPress) The Karnataka High Court has dismissed two petitions that contested the Congress-led state government’s mandate requiring new electricity consumers to install smart pre-paid meters. Reports indicate that the expenses associated with these smart pre-paid meters are significantly higher compared to neighboring states.
A Bench presided over by Justice M. Nagaprasanna observed that a similar petition is currently before the Division Bench of the High Court, leading to the dismissal of the petitions in this instance.
The court has adjourned the case to July 22 for further examination.
Previously, the court criticized the government, pointing out that while the installation cost for pre-paid smart meters in other states is fixed at Rs 900, Karnataka is charging an exorbitant Rs 8,900 for the same meters.
The court raised concerns, questioning, “Where will the poor go?” and highlighted the potential dangers of outsourcing such work.
Additionally, the court issued an interim order preventing the state government from enforcing the procurement of smart pre-paid meters as a condition for electricity supply.
Senior counsel for the petitioners, Lakshmy Iyengar, argued that all consumers would ultimately be obligated to switch to smart meters.
In contrast, Advocate General Shashi Kiran Shetty clarified that only new homes are mandated to install smart meters, and this regulation does not extend to existing customers.
In a related development regarding the smart meter controversy, a BJP delegation approached Governor Thaawarchand Gehlot on Wednesday, urging him to sanction an investigation against Energy Minister K.J. George under Section 17A of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988.
This marks the second instance the BJP has requested prosecution against Minister George concerning this issue.
Addressing the smart meter situation, BJP state president and MLA B.Y. Vijayendra accused the Congress-led government of facilitating incidents of exploitation since taking office.
He recalled prior discussions where Leader of the Opposition R. Ashoka and former Deputy Chief Minister C.N. Ashwath Narayan had sought the Governor’s permission to prosecute the minister. “We have reiterated our request on this matter,” he stated.
The representation to the Governor alleged that Minister George, in collusion with Bangalore Electricity Supply Company (Bescom) officials, engaged in multiple violations related to the smart meter tender, aiming to illicitly enrich themselves via a shell company.
Point of View
It's crucial to approach this situation with a balanced perspective. While the Karnataka High Court's decision underscores the government's push for modernization, the financial burden on consumers cannot be overlooked. A transparent dialogue between the government and citizens is vital to ensure that the transition to smart meters is equitable and just.
NationPress
08/10/2025
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the ruling of the Karnataka High Court regarding smart meters?
The Karnataka High Court dismissed petitions against the mandatory installation of smart pre-paid meters for new electricity consumers, asserting the state's authority to implement this regulation.
Why are smart pre-paid meters more expensive in Karnataka?
The cost of smart pre-paid meters in Karnataka is significantly higher, priced at Rs 8,900, compared to Rs 900 in neighboring states, raising concerns about affordability.
Will existing electricity consumers be affected by this decision?
No, the ruling applies only to new housing constructions; existing consumers are not required to switch to smart meters.
What are the political implications of this ruling?
The ruling has sparked political tensions, with the BJP demanding investigations into alleged corruption involving the Energy Minister related to the smart meter procurement process.
What steps are being taken to address the high costs of smart meters?
The court has called for transparency and fairness in the pricing of smart meters, emphasizing the need for the government to address affordability issues for consumers.
