Is the Masala Bond Scandal a Major Financial Fraud Favoring a Canadian Firm?
Click to start listening
Synopsis
On December 1, senior Congress member Ramesh Chennithala claimed the Masala Bond issue is a significant fraud in Kerala, benefiting a Canadian firm linked to the SNC-Lavalin scandal. Allegations against top officials arise as the ED investigates potential FEMA violations, sparking political controversy and raising questions about financial governance.
Key Takeaways
- Masala Bonds linked to a major financial scandal.
- Allegations involve political figures and possible corruption.
- High interest rates raise concerns about financial governance.
- Enforcement Directorate investigates FEMA violations.
- Impact on Kerala’s political landscape likely.
Thiruvananthapuram, Dec 1 (NationPress) Senior Congress figure and CWC member Ramesh Chennithala on Monday accused the Masala Bond situation of being one of the largest financial frauds in Kerala's history, asserting it primarily benefited a Canadian firm tied to the controversial SNC-Lavalin case.
On that same day, reports emerged that the Enforcement Directorate has issued notices to Chief Minister Pinarayi Vijayan, former Finance Minister Thomas Isaac, and others for purported breaches of the Foreign Exchange Management Act (FEMA) concerning the issuance and utilization of Masala Bonds by the Kerala Infrastructure Investment Fund Board (KIIFB).
Chennithala charged CM Vijayan and Isaac with favoring the Canadian pension fund CDPQ by issuing Masala Bonds at an exorbitant interest rate of 9.72 percent, while comparable Indian bonds were accessible internationally at rates between 5.5 and 7.5 percent, and World Bank rates hovered around 2.5 percent.
The Congress leader pointed out that CDPQ held a 20 percent stake in SNC-Lavalin — the Canadian engineering and construction firm implicated in a Rs 375-crore case where CM Vijayan was the seventh accused — and that the Masala Bond agreement was arranged to benefit the Canadian firm through a private placement prior to its public listing on the London Stock Exchange.
“The bonds were covertly allocated before March 29, 2019, and the funds had already been transferred to KIIFB. However, on April 1, the Chief Minister traveled to London solely to announce the listing,” he stated, claiming it was a political facade concealing a premeditated transaction.
He contrasted this with other development loans, such as those from the Asian Development Bank, which were available at rates below 4 percent, noting that Kerala had previously secured financing for Kochi Metro at 1.35 percent and Water Metro at 1.55 percent.
Nonetheless, Masala Bonds amounting to Rs 2,150 crore were issued at 9.72 percent, incurring an interest expense of Rs 1,045 crore for the state, leading to a total repayment of Rs 3,195 crore.
“The only genuine beneficiary was CDPQ,” he asserted.
Chennithala also dismissed the recent notice from the Enforcement Directorate as a pre-election tactic, claiming it was aimed at dispelling rumors of a "hidden alliance" between the BJP and CPI(M).
“Similar to the gold smuggling case, this too will dissipate due to the cordial ties between Narendra Modi and Pinarayi Vijayan,” he claimed.
Furthermore, he mentioned that even the Comptroller and Auditor General (CAG) had noted rule breaches in the issuance of these bonds.
Point of View
It is crucial to approach the allegations surrounding the Masala Bonds with an unbiased lens. The claims made by Ramesh Chennithala raise significant questions regarding financial governance in Kerala, especially concerning the potential implications for political figures involved. The investigation by the Enforcement Directorate adds a layer of complexity that must be monitored closely.
NationPress
01/12/2025
Frequently Asked Questions
What are Masala Bonds?
Masala Bonds are rupee-denominated bonds issued to overseas investors, allowing them to invest in Indian projects while hedging against currency risks.
What is the SNC-Lavalin case?
The SNC-Lavalin case involves allegations of corruption and fraud linked to a Canadian engineering firm, with political figures in Kerala facing scrutiny.
What is the role of the Enforcement Directorate?
The Enforcement Directorate (ED) is responsible for enforcing economic laws and fighting financial crime in India, including violation of the Foreign Exchange Management Act.
Why is the interest rate on these bonds controversial?
The interest rate of 9.72% for Masala Bonds is significantly higher than rates available for similar Indian bonds, raising concerns about financial favoritism.
What are the implications if allegations are proven true?
If proven, the allegations could lead to significant political fallout for current leaders and raise questions about financial governance in Kerala.
