Why Did Sharmistha Get Arrested? NHRC Member Priyank Kanoongo Demands Report from West Bengal
Click to start listening
Synopsis
The NHRC has intervened in the case of Sharmistha Panoli, a law student arrested for communal remarks. With significant public figures supporting her, questions arise about the legality of her arrest. This case highlights the balance between freedom of speech and the law's boundaries.
Key Takeaways
- NHRC demands a report on Sharmistha's safety.
- Sharmistha was arrested for alleged communal remarks.
- Public figures like Kangana Ranaut support her release.
- Kolkata Police justify their actions legally.
- The incident raises questions about freedom of speech.
New Delhi, June 2 (NationPress) The NHRC has requested a report from the West Bengal government and police regarding the well-being of Sharmistha Panoli, a jailed law student and content creator, within 10 days. This inquiry raises questions about the legality of her arrest.
NHRC Member Priyank Kanoongo informed IANS, “We have issued a notice to both the Chief Secretary and the police chief following complaints about potential irregularities in the arrest procedures involving Panoli, including her transit remand.”
Kanoongo emphasized, “We expect the report to be submitted within a span of 10 days.”
The 22-year-old was detained on Saturday in Gurugram, Haryana, by Kolkata Police for sharing videos with communal remarks during Operation Sindoor.
Prominent Bollywood actress Kangana Ranaut voiced her support for Panoli’s immediate release, deeming her arrest related to a now-deleted social media post as 'unwarranted'.
Kangana, recognized for portraying strong female characters, expressed concern over the negative impact on the influencer's career due to her detention by Kolkata Police.
“No girl or daughter should endure such authoritative behavior,” Ranaut stated while addressing the media during an event in Delhi.
Directing criticism at the Trinamool government of West Bengal, the National Award-winning actress and BJP MP from Mandi in Himachal Pradesh remarked, “I urge the West Bengal government not to turn the state into another North Korea.”
“Every citizen is entitled to their democratic rights. If she made an objectionable remark, she later apologized. It appears she made her comment in a general context. Young people today often use such phrases,” she argued strongly for Sharmistha’s release.
Andhra Pradesh’s Deputy Chief Minister Pawan Kalyan also extended his support to Sharmistha, urging the West Bengal Police to act fairly.
As sympathy for the arrested influencer grows, the Kolkata Police sought to clarify the 'misleading narrative' concerning their actions and her controversial social media posts.
In a statement on social media platform X, the Kolkata Police defended their actions, asserting they adhered to legal protocols.
“Hate speech and abusive language should not be misinterpreted as freedom of expression as guaranteed by Article 19(1)(a) of the Constitution,” stated the police.
“The individual was not arrested for expressing patriotism or personal beliefs; legal actions were taken due to the dissemination of offensive content that incites hatred among communities,” they concluded.
Point of View
The incident involving Sharmistha Panoli raises critical questions about the intersection of free speech and legal accountability in India. While the NHRC's involvement underscores the need for a thorough investigation, it also highlights the public's growing concerns regarding state actions that may infringe upon personal freedoms. The case reflects broader societal tensions and the ongoing dialogue about individual rights.
NationPress
08/06/2025
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the allegations against Sharmistha Panoli?
Sharmistha Panoli is accused of making communal remarks in videos she posted on social media, which led to her arrest by Kolkata Police.
What has the NHRC requested from West Bengal authorities?
The NHRC has requested a report on the safety of Sharmistha Panoli within 10 days, questioning the legality of her arrest procedures.
Who has publicly supported Sharmistha Panoli?
Bollywood actress Kangana Ranaut and Andhra Pradesh Deputy Chief Minister Pawan Kalyan are among those who have voiced their support for Sharmistha.
How has the Kolkata Police defended their actions?
The Kolkata Police stated that their actions were lawful and emphasized the distinction between hate speech and freedom of expression.
What is the public reaction to Sharmistha's arrest?
There has been significant public sympathy for Sharmistha, with many arguing that her arrest is unjustified and raises concerns about freedom of speech.
