Sandpapergate: Johnson backs Bancroft, says Cummins captaincy 'can't survive'
Synopsis
Key Takeaways
Former Australian fast bowler Mitchell Johnson has publicly backed Cameron Bancroft's explosive account of the 2018 Sandpapergate scandal, declaring that he believes the pressure on Pat Cummins to relinquish the Test captaincy is now unstoppable. The intervention, published in a column for The West Australian on 19 November 2026, escalates a controversy that has rocked Australian cricket for the second time in eight years.
Johnson Backs Bancroft's Account
In his column, Johnson was unequivocal in his assessment of Bancroft's credibility. Bancroft had earlier written a 4,000-word piece for the same publication alleging that the 'whole team' knew about the use of sandpaper on the ball during the 2018 Cape Town Test — not just the three players formally punished: Steve Smith, David Warner, and Bancroft himself.
'I believe Bancroft's account. It comes across as real, and I could feel the words as he was saying them. He came across as himself, and he has nothing to lose now. It also lines up with the most detailed accounts we've heard from other players,' Johnson wrote.
Johnson's endorsement carries weight given his stature in Australian cricket, and his assertion that Bancroft's version 'lines up' with other accounts deepens the credibility problem for Cummins and his fellow bowlers.
Cummins Under Mounting Pressure
The timing is particularly sensitive for Cummins, who last week held a 70-minute press conference to deny claims made by teammate Usman Khawaja, dismissing them as 'complete and utter nonsense.' His agent, Neil Maxwell, reiterated on Thursday that the captain's 'position hasn't changed in eight years.'
Johnson, however, suggested that stonewalling is no longer viable. 'The pressure on Cummins is now immense. I think he will still try to stand by what he has said and his statement with all of the bowlers back in 2021. But I think the public pressure for Cummins to stand down as Test captain now will be too much. I just can't see how his captaincy and personal brand survives this,' he wrote.
Johnson also noted that apparent support for Cummins, as well as fellow bowlers Mitchell Starc, Josh Hazlewood, and Nathan Lyon, is at 'its lowest point' and is already casting a shadow over the Australian summer of cricket.
Young Players Caught in the Crossfire
Johnson reserved sympathy for emerging Australian cricketers being drawn into the controversy. Cooper Connolly was fielded questions about sandpaper before the final one-day international against England, while Jack Edwards — described by Johnson as 'a young, inexperienced player' — was sent to face the media after the series when stand-in skipper Mitchell Marsh declined to front the press conference.
'Cooper Connolly was asked about sandpaper and the players involved before the final one-day international against England. He doesn't need those questions. He was in school when it happened,' Johnson said, adding that such players should be 'enjoying' their cricket careers rather than managing institutional fallout.
Johnson Calls on Cricket Australia to Go Further
Cricket Australia (CA) has reportedly proposed an independent forum allowing members of the 2018 touring squad to voluntarily come forward and speak about the scandal. Johnson argued this falls significantly short of what is needed.
'CA needs to do more than a safe-space forum. It's owed to the fans, and they've had enough, like many of us. The investigation failed at the one thing it was meant to do, end this eight years ago with the right outcome. We want the truth, we want answers,' he said.
Notably, Johnson acknowledged the complexity of collective memory — 'There'll be variations of what happened in 2018. Everyone remembers things a little differently. But in the end, the truth is the truth' — but was clear that the current process is insufficient. With the Australian summer now underway and the controversy refusing to fade, the coming days are likely to force a reckoning for both Cummins and CA's leadership.