Cummins loses credibility but need not quit, says Ian Healy on ball-tampering row

Share:
Audio Loading voice…
Cummins loses credibility but need not quit, says Ian Healy on ball-tampering row

Synopsis

Ian Healy's blunt SEN Radio verdict cuts to the heart of the renewed Sandpapergate crisis: Cummins can keep the captaincy, but the credibility he built since 2018 has taken a serious, possibly irreversible hit — and the shadow now stretches to Hazlewood, Starc and Lyon as well.

Key Takeaways

Ian Healy said Pat Cummins does not need to resign as Australia's Test captain but has lost 'a big part of his credibility.' Cameron Bancroft recently claimed the entire Australian side knew about the sandpaper plan during the 2018 Cape Town Test .
Healy warned Cummins 'will struggle to captain the team' unless he responds decisively to Bancroft's account.
The personal legacies of Josh Hazlewood , Mitchell Starc , and Nathan Lyon are also described as tainted by the revelation.
Healy opposed a reinvestigation by Cricket Australia , calling it 'costly' and 'ugly' given the original inquiry was already mishandled.

Former Australia wicketkeeper Ian Healy has said Pat Cummins does not need to resign as Australia's Test captain in the wake of Cameron Bancroft's explosive fresh claims about the 2018 Cape Town ball-tampering scandal, but warned that Cummins has lost 'a big part of his credibility' following a press conference last week in which the captain indicated he was unaware of the plot.

What Bancroft Claimed

The renewed controversy stems from Bancroft's recent admission that the entire Australian side knew about the plan to use sandpaper on the ball during the Cape Town Test against South Africa, and that he had effectively 'taken the bullet' for the group. That claim directly contradicts the account Cummins offered at a press conference last week, where the captain said he and other bowlers were unaware of any such plan.

Healy's Verdict on Cummins

'No, he doesn't need to stand down. And I don't want to get into another panic mode of what happened in 2018, it was panic, and they tried to do an investigation in no time, didn't talk to anyone, it was rubbish. It was a lack of quality and rubbish, and rushed, and panicked,' Healy said on SEN Radio.

Healy added, however, that Cummins' position as leader had been materially weakened. 'He will struggle to captain the team. You've had a big part of your credibility taken away with that press conference now that it's been proven to be not as complete as Pat made it out to be,' he said.

Shadow Over Hazlewood, Starc and Lyon

Healy extended his assessment beyond Cummins, arguing the scandal also casts a shadow over fellow bowlers from that series — Josh Hazlewood, Mitchell Starc, and Nathan Lyon. 'I would say it taints their personal legacies. I don't think it's going to taint their performance legacies,' he said. He suggested the ball-tampering may have been occurring for longer than previously acknowledged: 'They got very brazen with it, so that tells me it's probably been going on longer than we think.'

Darren Lehmann and Cricket Australia

Healy, who played 119 Tests and 168 ODIs for Australia between 1988 and 1999, also turned his attention to then-head coach Darren Lehmann, saying the time was right for Lehmann to tell his side of the story, but that the picture was already becoming clear. 'It was an ugly underbelly with an average attitude, and he was in charge of it,' Healy remarked. On whether Cricket Australia should launch a reinvestigation, Healy was firm: 'No. I don't think there's any value in it. It would be costly, it would be ugly, and continuing something that should have been better handled first time.'

What Happens Next

The fallout from Bancroft's revelations continues to ripple through Australian cricket, arriving at a particularly sensitive moment with the Border-Gavaskar Trophy series against India looming. Whether Cummins opts to publicly address the claims again — or whether Cricket Australia steps in — is likely to define the narrative around the Australian Test team in the days ahead.

Point of View

At a press conference last week, offered an account that now appears incomplete at best. Healy's formulation — 'doesn't need to stand down, but will struggle to captain' — is a polite way of saying the authority is hollow. Australia's dressing room heading into a high-stakes Test series against India will now carry a question mark that no on-field performance can easily erase. The original Cricket Australia investigation was always criticised as rushed and narrow; the refusal to revisit it now means the fog stays, and with it, the credibility damage to everyone who was in that Cape Town XI.
NationPress
19 Nov 2026

Frequently Asked Questions

What did Ian Healy say about Pat Cummins resigning as Test captain?
Ian Healy said Cummins does not need to stand down as Australia's Test captain, but warned he has lost 'a big part of his credibility' following Cameron Bancroft's fresh claims about the 2018 ball-tampering scandal. Healy added that Cummins would 'struggle to captain the team' unless he directly refutes Bancroft's account.
What did Cameron Bancroft claim about the 2018 ball-tampering incident?
Bancroft recently claimed that the entire Australian side knew about the plan to use sandpaper on the ball during the Cape Town Test against South Africa in 2018, and that he 'took the bullet' for the group. This directly contradicts statements Pat Cummins made at a press conference last week.
Which other Australian players does the scandal now implicate, according to Healy?
Healy said the revelations taint the personal legacies of bowlers Josh Hazlewood, Mitchell Starc, and Nathan Lyon, all of whom were part of the 2018 Australian Test squad. He distinguished between their performance legacies, which he said remain intact, and their personal credibility.
Should Cricket Australia launch a fresh investigation into the ball-tampering scandal?
Ian Healy argued against a reinvestigation, calling it 'costly' and 'ugly' and saying the original inquiry was already rushed and poorly handled. He believes the picture is now clear enough without spending further resources on a formal probe.
What is Ian Healy's view of Darren Lehmann's role in the 2018 scandal?
Healy said the 'dots have been joined' regarding then-head coach Darren Lehmann's awareness of the situation, describing the environment under Lehmann as 'an ugly underbelly with an average attitude.' He said if Lehmann wants to tell his side of the story, 'now's the time.'
Nation Press
The Trail

Connected Dots

Tracing the thread behind this story — newest first.

8 Dots
  1. Latest 2 hours ago
  2. 5 hours ago
  3. Yesterday
  4. 2 days ago
  5. 6 days ago
  6. 1 week ago
  7. 1 week ago
  8. 1 week ago
Google Prefer NP
On Google