Sandpapergate probe should reopen if Australians want answers: Irfan Pathan
Synopsis
Key Takeaways
Former India all-rounder Irfan Pathan has called for the Sandpapergate investigation to be reopened if Australian fans and media are still seeking answers, while expressing sympathy for Cameron Bancroft, whose international career was effectively derailed by the 2018 ball-tampering scandal. Pathan made the remarks on JioStar's programme 'Sandpapergate: The Unsettled Debate', engaging with the controversy freshly reignited by Usman Khawaja's claims in his autobiography.
Pathan's Sympathy for Bancroft
Bancroft received a nine-month ban for his role in the scandal during the 2018 Cape Town Test against South Africa. While former captain Steve Smith and vice-captain David Warner each served one-year bans and went on to revive their careers, Bancroft returned to play just two Tests for Australia after serving his suspension.
'I really feel bad for Cameron Bancroft because he lost everything. He played only two Test matches after serving a nine-month ban. It's always the youngsters, the weaker ones, who get punished the most,' Pathan said. He pointed out that Smith eventually captained Australia again in Pat Cummins's absence, and Warner played a substantial number of international matches before retiring — while Bancroft's story remained largely ignored.
Should the Investigation Be Reopened?
Pathan acknowledged that Cricket Australia's original inquiry lasted just four days before being concluded. While he stopped short of demanding a fresh probe, he said circumstances warranted one if public demand existed. 'What has happened, happened. There was a four-day investigation by Cricket Australia, and it was done and dusted. I understand Usman Khawaja's point of view because everyone deserves to write their book,' he said. 'But if something has happened, and if Australian media and people want answers, then the investigation should start again,' Pathan added.
Pathan Questions Bowlers' Claimed Ignorance
Pathan also raised pointed questions about whether Australian bowlers could genuinely have been unaware of the tampering. 'It's not possible that, if the ball is reverse swinging and as a bowler, I won't know if something has been done to the ball. I'll know straight away,' he said.
Drawing on personal experience, he noted that the only time he encountered unexplained reverse swing in his career was during a Duleep Trophy match in Rajkot, where extremely dry conditions naturally produced the effect from as early as the 8th or 10th over. 'But if you put something on the ball around the 30th or 40th over, when its colour has changed, you will know as a bowler. The entire team knows what's happening with the ball at any given time,' he said.
Khawaja's Claims and the Wider Fallout
The debate was reignited after Usman Khawaja alleged in his book 'Sabr' that the entire Australian team was aware of the sandpaper being used on the ball during the Cape Town Test, and that similar tactics had been employed in the preceding Test at Port Elizabeth. Warner reportedly backed Khawaja's claims, while current Australian captain Pat Cummins dismissed them as 'complete and utter nonsense.'
Smith was also handed a two-year leadership ban at the time, while Warner's lifetime leadership ban was partially lifted — he was permitted to apply for leadership roles from 2024 onward, following a review. The diverging career trajectories of the three punished players, and the sharp disagreement among current and former Australian players, suggest the scandal's legacy remains far from settled.
What Comes Next
With Khawaja's book continuing to generate reaction across the cricket world, pressure on Cricket Australia to revisit its findings — or at least clarify the scope of the original inquiry — is likely to grow. How the governing body responds, and whether the Australian public demands greater accountability, could determine whether Sandpapergate finally reaches a definitive conclusion.